Yuraqanchyur mardkayin haraberutyun hakvac em ditelu vorpes erkkoghmani hamadzaynutyun ev, inchpes divanagitakan haraberutyan depqum e, erb mi koghmy xaxtum e kanonnery, apa erkrordn iravunq uni cheghyal hamarel ayn: Haytni e, vor xabum en nran, vov uzum e linel xabvac, ev yuraqanchyur mard uni urishnerin gnahatelu miayn iren hatuk kerp: elnelov ir stereotipic: Barekamners xorhurd tvecin chgrel suyn hodvacy: aselov, vor aydpes teghekutyunner em haghordum naev im masin: Sa iharke harci tesaneli koghmn e miayn, isk aravel xory ditarkumnery erevutacnum en verjinis ayl, gaghtni voraknery: Kartch: erb problemy toghnum es chlucvac, dran avelanum e evs meky, heto noric, ev Abrahamyan Surik anunov meky, qcnelov aj u dzax, phordzum e zrkel qez iravunqneric, u sociumy mshtapes yndunum e ayn, inch nran hramcnum en, na sirum e krkesy, isk haci gerxndri u krkesi mijev mshtapes tuzhum e mtacogh anhaty:

Zaveshtov u cavov ardzanagrum em, vor «Erkxosutyun: menaxosakan drvagnerov» («GT», 2013, 3, ej 6-7) «scenari» hogevarqayin verapruknery, voronq yndameny storakarg u chhimnavorvac bambasanqner en (och mi gitakan togh chka nranum) phoxancvel en naev suyny grogh «scenaristnerin» : Sergey Sarinyan, Abrahamyan Surik, u verjinners korcrel en irenc voch miayn mardkayin, aylev tghamardkayin dimagcery: cucadrelov aravelapes bnazdnery, qan banakan mardun kam gitnakanin vayel pahvacqy:
Tes ev hmmt:
I
a. Sergey Sarinyany grum e: «Ev aha mtnum e ancanot meky ev nerkayanum. «Es Naira Hambardzumyann em, ereveli anunneri () kariq unem, () ev ayd amboghjy katarel e im gitakan ghekavar Sevak Arzumanyany ()» («GT», 2013, 3, ej 6):
a/1. Sergey Sarinyany stum e, qani vor «Kanach karetner» (2004) banasteghcutyunneri zhoghovacun tpagrvel e Sevak Arzumanyani mahic mot tasy amis anc (dektemberi 10-15), ev nuynisk boreniamit yntercoghin el parz e, vor tvyal zhamanakahatvacum S. Sarinyany voreve shphum cher karogh unenal Sevak Arzumanyani het: Isk ete na ir bazmativ «taghandneri» koghqin (inchpes: hracanov gerezmanaqareri aranqum taqnvely (tes S. Sarinyan, Hayoc grakanutyan erku dary, // «I hetchuks», 2009, h. 5, ej 350) ) uni naev andrshirimyan haghordakcutyan hnaravorutyunner, da arden ayl xosakcutyun e, sakayn karcum em: chaphazanc anharmar e u amot lusahogi Sevak Arzumanyani anuny nman kerp shaharkely:
b. Sergey Sarinyany grum e: «Yndunum em inchpes kargn e, bayc bacum em girqy ev inchpisi anaknkal: arajabany ev xmbagrumy ??? Sergey Sarinyani» («GT», 2013, 3, ej 6):
b/1. Sergey Sarinyany stum e, qani vor «Kanach karetner» zhoghovacui arajabani heghinaky inqy che (tes N. Hambardzumyan, «Kanach karetner», «Lusakn», 2004, 86 ej), isk xmbagrumy katarel e mec sirov, voric ayzhm hrazharvum e: Verjin xmbagrman hamar nerkayacrel em voch te girqy, ayl banasteghcutyunneri ejadrvac tarberaky: september amsin:
g. Sergey Sarinyany grum e: «Es … vrdovmunqs artahayteci Sevakin nman ararqi hamar ???» («GT», 2013, 3, ej 6):
g/1. Sergey Sarinyany stum e, qani vor im koghmic makagrvac zhoghovacun na stacel e 2005-i phetrvari keserin, hetevabar cher karogh ir vrdovmunqn artahaytel Sevak Arzumanyanin haytni pattcharnerov:
d. Sergey Sarinyany xeghatyurel e «Entropia kam +37» xoragrov banasteghcutyuns: ktratelov toghery, aghtchatelov mitqy, arvazn votnaharel e im heghinakayin iravunqy (tes «GT», 2013, 3, ej 6):
Tes ev hmmt: N. Hambardzumyan: Dzandzruyt. Ev cary nman che carin, Ev qary nman che qarin, Ev hoghy serm chi ororum, Ev mardy chi ptghavorvum, Voch mutq, voch elq, Voch skizb, voch verj, Voch el: ptuyt. Dzandzruyt: TI-E-ZE - RA -KAN…
V. Hakobyani toghery: Caghiky chgitem inch er, bayc caghik cher…Aghbyury chgitem inch er, bayc aghbyur cher…Erkinqy chgitem inch er, bayc erkinq cher…
Karcum em, petq che graget linel: tesnelu hamar, vor sranq tarber banasteghcutyunner en:
e. Sergey Sarinyany grum e: «Erb Davit Hovhannesn asum e, te «es bar em dardzel», apa da ir xorqum uni taghandi nerqin tarapanqy ev kataryali nerqin dzgtumy () (ur e himnavorumy: N.H.): Bayc ete mi diletant grchak nuynpes asum e, te: «bar em voronum», apa da imitacia e u baragoghutyun ??? (ur e himnavorumy: N.H.): Militonyany ir aryan bjijnerov e zgum vayrkyani haverzhutyuny…» () (tes «GT», 2013, 3, ej 7):
e/1. Sergey Sarinyany stum e, qanzi erbeq chem asel: «bar em voronum» », ev inqy hastat voch mi tegh chi kardacel suyn artahaytutyuny, u grqis xoragiry hetevyaln e: «Es bar em dardzel» (2008), qani angam kareli e krknel nuyny: Davit Hovhannesin vkayakochelu paragan nuynpes petq er nshel phastov, taretvov ev voch te odum canel barer, heto moranal, te inchi masin e xosqy u hghel Ed. Militonyani anuny: Sranq nuynpes qnnadatakan motavor - a - pesutyan var apacuycner en:
z. Ushagrav mi phast evs. suyn «asuytneri» qich seghm tarberaky karogh eq yntercel: S. Sarinyan, Hayoc grakanutyan erku dary, (2009, h. 5, ej 544 - 550) grqum: Ayn grvel e i patasxan Yura Xachatryani «Akademikosi pertchanqn u tshvarutyuny» hodvacin, iharke, «I hetchuks» hushagrutyan 268-271 ejery xnamqov xmbagreluc heto: Ays angam el akademikosy chi xusaphel inqnartagrumic u kaghaparneric: Yura Xachatryan-y phoxarinelov Naira Hambardzumyan anvamb: Nshanabann u barapasharn el nuynn en, qanzi boloris e haytni: Sarinyany sovorakan baxtagushak che, ayl: «ereveli»:
e. Petq e xorapes hiastaphecnem akademikosin. «havaqarari kecvacq» artahaytutyuny («GT», 2013, 3, ej 6) suyn entateqstum ditum em vorpes araqelutyun: Surikin u nra steghcac qnnadatakan aghby maqrelu: I verjo, shat havaqararner, pahakner, banjaravatcharner kam hanqaphorner tarrakan kultura unen u mardkanc varkabekelu ev viravorelu gavaramit snobizmic hastat bardzr en: Isk amenatarber anmakardak vorakumneri hastatumy kam zhxtumy mimiayn MECN Zhamanaki xndirn e, u «ereveli» baxtagushakn aystegh hastat ANZVoR e:
H. G. Hetaqrqir e: aysqanic heto inch nkati uni Sergey Sarinyany, erb xosum e tchakatagrin nuynacogh «genetik skzbi» masin: Ardyoq veronshyal aghavaghumnery aravel tesaneli chen dardznum suyn erkxosutyan «erevelii» voch miayn genetik skizby, aylev: mutacianery: Hamenayndeps, papiks Stalingradi tchakatamarti masnakic er, hashmandam ev hracany dzerqin cher taqnvel gerezmanaqareri aranqum…, isk mecatun naxniners (chem vaxenum ayd bary greluc) derevs 17-rd daraverjin Naxijevani «Tchahuk-Shahaponq» teghanqum erku ekegheci en karucel, 19-rd darum veranorogel ekegheciner u, zbaghvelov lusavorchakan u hovanavorchakan gorcuneutyamb, grel-kardal en sovorecrel bolor suikanmannerin, vori hamar stacel en Phirghalamyan (surb grich) azganuny (tes Argam Ayvazyan, «Naxijevani vimagrakan zharangutyuny», h. Z, E., 2010):

II
Inch veraberum e hnamash, bayc «philisophayakan qnnadatutyamb» li portfely tevi tak «global harcer» arajadrogh akademiakan gragrin, apa sa vaghuc iren u ir «hantcharegh mtqery» sparac artagrogh generator e, qanzi sra nmannery karogh en miayn mogonel hatkapes 1937-in harir temanerov, inchpes: «Mer grakanutyan zargacman mitumnery u dran xangarogh hakaheghaphoxakan tarrery» kam: «Voch ughegh, voch karciq, voch mtacelakerp. miayn: gorshutyun»: Sra nshanabann e: koghoptel arevmtyan tesabannerin: Hetevenq suyni «mtqi trichqnerin»:
a. XX dari 60-70-akan tvakannerin arevmtyan (hatkapes: amerikyan) pahpanoghakan tesabanakan koghmnoroshumy miangamayn zgushavorutyamb verabervec inchpes Yulia Kristevayi «tesakan anarxizmin», aynpes el: telqelakannerin, bacarutyamb: Rolan Barti, vov hetkarucvacqabanutyan andzernmxelineri cucakum er: Ayd pattcharov el Kristevayi masnakcutyuny ev azdecutyuny hetkarucvacqabanutyan naxnakan dzevavorman phulerum: yeylakan dproci vordegrac ev fenomenologiakan ughghutyunnerov, nvazaguyn e: Kristevayi haghtarshavy aravelapes nkatvec hetkarucvacqabanutyan hetaga zargacumnerum, erb na heghinakec postmodernistakan «interteqst» haskacutyuny, inchpes naev barenpast hogh steghcec feministakan sharzhman azdecutyan u qnnadatutyan hamar ev vorpes gitnakan-tesaban ughghakioren kangnec hetkarucvacqabanutyan akunqnerum: Kristevan qnnadatec karucvacqabanutyan druytnery, dzevakerpec u himnavorec subyekti apakentronacman u grakan teqsti a-karucvacqaynutyan veraberyal ymbrnumnery: Qnnadatelov Deridayin: artahaytec mitqy, te Deridayi «O grammatologii» ashxatanqi qaghaqakanutyuny ughghvac e nax ev araj fenomenologiayi qnnadatutyany, vorn i verjo hangecnum e «negativ» qnnadatutyan «pozitivacmany»: Sakayn suyn mitqy artahaytely derevs chi nshanakum, te Kristevan fenomenologiakan hayacqner uni, inchpes haytnagorcum e suyny (tes «GT», 2013, 3, ej 7), qanzi Kristevayi ashxatanqnery ditarkeli en nax ev araj interteqstualutyan ev lezvabanakan hogebanutyan tesankyunneric ev Aritmia erevuytin (orpes aydpisin) nuynpes chuni andradardzner:
b. Suyny xeghatyurel e naev im: «Inchpes yntercel. Yntercogh-teqst-heghinak» hodvaci xoragiry ev nranum amphophvac druytnery (tes «Garun», 2012, 5-6, ej 32-38) : aghavaghelov u xarnelov Aritmia essein (tes «GT» havelvac, 2012, 19 hokt., ej 4): Kristevayic bervac mtqeri koghqin, kuyri hamar el tesaneliutyun apahovelov, nshel em nra anuny, inchy hamapatasxanum e sahmanvac normerin, inchpes: «Cankacac nuynakanutyun hnaravor e ev kaskaci entarkel (ete ditenq mez koghqic), bayc karogh enq ev hasnel ayn bard haskacutyan euytin, vory metafizikakan apakarucum anunn e krum, tepet ayd tiruyt, yst Yulia Kristevayi, taphancel en arayzhm miayn Nicshen, Haydegery, Hanna Arendty, masamb: Froydy, vov arajin hertin tesnum er naxapasharvac mardu tchakatagiry» (tes «Garun», 2012, 5-6, ej 32): I dep, suyni berac mtqery, ibrev te: Kristevayi gorcuneutyan volorti shurj (mshakutayin melos, fenomenologia, paytyun, ev ayln) trcvac en henc Aritmia esseic, inchi zhanrayin tarberutyuny nuynisk chi patkeracrel suyn tgety (hodvac e, te esse): Suyny canot che naev Kristevayi usumnasirutyan volortnerin: 1. Zhest. praktika ili kommunikaciya // Izbrannie trudi: Razrushenie poetiki, M., 2004, 2. Otvrashchenie // Sili uzhasa: esse ob otvrashchenii, SPB., Aleteyya, 2003, 3. Dusha i obraz // Filosofskaya misl Francii XX veka, Tomsk: Vodoley, 1998, ev ayln: 4. Chitaya Bibliyu // Filosofskaya misl Francii XX veka, Tomsk: Vodoley, 1998, 5. Smert v Vizantii (roman), M., 2007, 6. Rebenok s neviskazannim smislom // Filosofskaya misl Francii XX veka, Tomsk: Vodoley, 1998 ev ayln:
g. «Aritmia» esseic ev «Inchpes yntercel. Yntercogh-teqst-heghinak» hodvacic qaghelov mi qani artahaytutyunner: «ashxarhy mi mec universum», «andzi nuynakanacum», «mardik tiezerakan ankshreliutyan mej», «Es-y atomi mej», «texnogen hasarakutyun» suyny kcmcel e mimyanc u ankatarutyan patranq steghcel: De ari u sran haskacru, vor inqy nuynisk gratchanachutyan tarrakan normerin chi tirapetum, mek phsxvacqum tasnyak ughghagrakan, ketadrakan u sharadasakan sxalner e katarum, isk tarber vernagrer u anunner sxal grely sra mot ughghaki orenqi sahmannerum e: orinak: Zaven Piperyani «Mrjyunneru verjaluysy» : «mrjyunneru veradardzy» (teghi sghutyan pattcharov berum em miayn mek orinak): Ays paymannerum atomayin fizika-astghafizika-sociologia-subyekt-obyekt-Es-qaghaqagitutyun-kensafizika-lezvahogebanutyun erevuytnery sra ugheghin inchpes khasnen, che vor tgitutyunn u mijakutyuny zoravor uzher en:
d. Gaghtniq che, vor lotosi atchecman paymannerin arnchvogh nshyal mitqy arka e naev cankacac hanragitaranum: Ayn yntercel u nranic ogtvel karogh en bolory: Veronshyaly zugaherel em mshakutaxegh irakanutyan (ori tghmot u garshahot bacilakirn e suyny) u nranum aprogh normal mardu goyutyan paymannerin (i dep, dra liarzheq iravunqn unenalov) : «Stacvum e: mardn aprum e lotosi kyanqov, vori armatnery tighmi mej en, isk spitak, karmir, kapuyt tertiknery bacvum en patranqneri phophoxakan ashxarhnerum» («Garun», 2011, 5-6, ej 33): Isk te suyny inch e phntrel buddistakan kroni druytnery bacatrogh kayqum: patasxanatu e miayn inqy, ev indz mnum e sosk Daniel Varuzhani nman dzerq taph tal: «Vo˜v cexahogi, vov piti sga qu vaxtchand…», isk erknqic lsvum e Av. Isahakyani margareakan dzayny: «Es dzez asum em: kga vogu sov …»: Harc: «GT» -i suyn hogevarqayin tprtocnery inch-or kerp tarbervum en veronshyal tighmic:
e. Akademiakan suyn mragri hnchecrac meghadrakan hetevyal gorcy: «N. Hambardzumyani gorcy kareli e anvanel «meknabanakan imitacia» …» (nax: «Grak. handesum», ej 79 ev apa: «GT» suyn konvulsiayum), aravelapes 1937 tvakani anstoragir matnagreri eutyann e mitum, qan te uni gitakan entateqst: Sra dzgtumy: tchanaparhic otarel yuraqanchyurin, vov gone phoqr-inch sparnum e ir «peghumnerin», sahmanner chi tchanachum, qanzi bolorin meghadrum e hatkapes ayn aghteghutyunnerum: «entateqstic ktrvac keghc phaster ev mejberumner, makeresayin u chcackagrvogh targmanutyunner aylevayl teqsteric, tarber tegheric katarvac baraci qaghvacqner: aranc chakertneri, mimyanc kcmcac barer, kapakcutyunner, artahaytutyunner», voronc nshanavor masnagetn e inqy, ev voronq vtangavor en aghandavorutyan chaph u qaraki anbaro: Ushagrav en hetevyal ditarkumnery:
1. 2012 t. skzbin suyni het mi banavor zruycum (masnakicnery voghj ev aroghj en) nshel em, vor ete tvyal hodvacum npataks Sergey Sarinyani «andardzutyan» philisophayutyuny imitaciayi entarkely liner, apa aydqan herun chei gna, qani vor nuyny arka e nax ev araj V. Partizunu «Vahan Teryan» menagrutyan mej (tes V. Partizuni, V. Teryan, E., 1964), vorn aveli vagh e grvel, qan kazmvel e «Hay grakanutyan patmutyan» 5-rd hatory: Baci ayd, asel em naev, vor akademikosi «Hayoc grakanutyan erku dary» grqi (tes h. 1, 1988, ej 336-430) «V. Teryani poezian» hodvacum baraci artagrutyunner kan Teryanic (tes «Garun», 2012, 9-10), ev chakertneri linel-chlineln el vochinch chi voroshum, vorovhetev hghum nuynpes chka: Uremn inch e stacvum erkaki ays xaghum. amenahimarin el parz e: bari kamqov lecun suyn mijakutyan npataky akademikosi gragoghutyunneri masin mek angam evs hanrutyany teghyak paheln e, vorpeszi heto «xnamqov» «phrki» nran u «phrkelov» : krkin nshi plagiati ejery, vorpeszi anteghyak yntercoghn el karda:
2. Nshel em naev (banavor), vor im «Banasteghci haytnutyuny» hodvaci arancqum «Bazmavep» -um K. V. storagrutyamb tpagrvac mi hodvac e, vori heghinaky Venetiki Mxitaryan miabanutyan qahananeric e, ev vor tvyal hodvacy Teryani: Verlenic u Bodleric katarac targmanutyunneri u drancic azdvelu aritov e: Grchaky karogh er stugel kam gone mek angam kardal hodvacy:
3. Verjins moranum e naev, vor «Dismorfomaniayi» mijakuhu «Mifi, te apamifakanacvac banasteghcutyuny» (tes «GT», 15 hulisi, 2011t., ej 7) hodvacy qnnadatelu xorhurdy evs inqn e tvel (nkatumners tghtin handznelu arumov) (tes «Garun», 2012, 7-8) u hima suyn phsxvacqum phordzum e «phrkel» naev sran (tes «GT», 2013, 3, ej 6-7): Ays dzernacuin tvum e, te atchpararakan mi qani gorcoghutyunner miangamic katarelov karogh e mnal anpatizh, u te: karevory aragutyunn e:
z. Ayd e vkayum naev «Teqst ev bnagir» (2010) girqy, qanzi tgitutyan ayd xraxtchanqum suyny gerazancum e mtagoghutyan, gragoghutyan, aghavaghumneri u cinizmi tchanacheli u antchanacheli bolor sahmannery: Orinak: zargacnelov binarutyan gaghaphary: suyny sahunoren miavorum e ayn tarberutyan (differance) u havelman (supplement) gaghapharnerin: miazhamanak chnshelov teqstum, vor dranq phoxarel e Deridayic ev suplement barum mek: petq e lini: supplement, isk diference barum katarelov erku ughghagrakan sxalner. petq e lini: differance, qanzi ete qvazin ushadir liner, apa ktesner, vor Deridayi hamanun grqi xoragiry voch te Diference e, inchpes nshum e canotagrutyunneri sharqum ev apa vorpes termin nuyn kerp ogtagorcum teqstum (tes Teqst ev bnagir, ej 150 ev ej 166, can. 9), ayl: La Differance, 1968: Angleren tarberaky: Differance, rusereny: Differanse), ev vor ayd erku terminneri mijev hskayakan tarberutyunner kan, voronq el tesaneli en dardznum sxal meknutyan himqery: «La Differance» ashxatanqum Deridan, usumnasirelov goyabanutyan u linelutyan tarberutyuny, nkatum e, vor Haydegery chi sheshtum tvyal tarberutyuny u verjnakanapes chi tarbazhanum linelutyunn u goyavory: ditarkelov vorpes Linelutyan bacahaytman u cackagrman gorcaruytneri dadar, voronq kazmavorvum en tvyal karuyci mijocov: Usti erb Haydegery Linelutyun bary grum e mecatarov, uremn xosqy hatkapes Linelutyan masin e ev voch te es gibt - i (goyabanutyan tarberakman): Ogtagorcelov ayn: Deridan mi koghmic pahpanum e racionalutyan nurb shertery, myus koghmic anjatum e logocentrizmi hretorakanutyunic: nerarelov tarberakman avandakan dzevery (Nicshe, Sosyur, Froyd, Levinas, Haydeger) u miavorum e hamashxarhayin tntesakan hamakargin, vory dzevavorum e hetevyal ymbrnumnery: archi-trace, supplement, dissemination, ev ayln: «La Differance-um», - nshum e Zhak Deridan, - haytnaberum enq inch-or phoxhatum, ayl voch te hashvarkum-nshanakum, vorn aravel hamozich nkaragrvac e mer serndi mtacutyunnerum: uzheri tarberakumy Nicshei mot, nshanabanakan tarberakman skzbunqy Sosyuri, tarberakumy vorpes ushacman effekt: Froydi mot, tarberakumy vorpes urishi hetq: Levinasi mot ev goya-goyabanakan haskacutyan tarberakumy Haydegeri mot (tes Derrida J., Differanse, // Margins of Philosophy // [ transl. by A. Bass] – Chicago: University of Chicago Press, 1982, p. 28): Sakayn sa erkaki divanagitakan xoramank qayl e, vorn argelakum e yntercman parzecman eghanaknery: i cuyc dnelov, vor differance-y erkxosutyan kam anti-erkxosutyan hatumic durs homogen goyacutyun che: Ayn inqnuruyn haskacutyun che, hetevabar haskacutyun che yndhanrapes: Sa hangamanq e, vor bacatrum e, te inchu differance-y chi karogh hamynknel voreve kentronakan ymbrnman: hakarak taracvac karciqi, te differance-y sosk himnarar skzbunqi hertakan erakn e (platonyan eydosy, hegelakan dialektikan, Marqsi dasakargayin payqary, Nicshei kamq ishxanutyan handep ymbrnumnery): Irakanum ayn haskacutyun kam ymbrnum che, aravel evs: verjnahangrvan kam npatakaughghvacutyun: Shat depqerum differance-y ughghakioren nuynacvum e difference-in, bayc aynuamenayniv chi karogh hasnel tarberutyan avandakan haskacutyany erku pattcharov:
a. differance-y tarbervum e difference-ic artadroghakan bnuytov: Ayn sovorakan tarberutyun che, ayl tarberakman hamakargeri artadramas: Shnorhiv a hnchyuni: differance-y harabervum e nran, inchy kareli e anvanel tarberutyunneri akunq kam artadrutyan yntacq, tarberutyunneri xagh» (tes nuyny, p.16): Usti steghcelov differance terminy: Deridan phoxarinum e latinakan - ence anartadroghakan acancy artadroghakan - ance acancov, vorov ev fransereny dzerq e berum nor bayahimq goyakanner (ayd tvum naev postmodernistakan erkxosutyan vorosh himnarar terminner ecrivance (R. Bart), provenance (Zh. Delyoz), signifiance (Yu. Kristeva) ): Ayspisov, a ev e hnchyunneri tarberutyuny uni skzbunqayin nshanakutyun, vory tesaneli e dardznum differnace-i artadroghakanutyuny:
b. Differance-y tramabanoren chi hamynknum difference-in, qani vor arajin terminy erku armatakan masnikneri arhestakan miakcumn e, voroncic meky kapvac e differer bayin (tarberakel, tarbervel), erkrordy: defer bayin (hetadzgum zhamanaki yntacqum): Hetevabar, differance-y nerarum e ev difference-y (tarberutyun) ev deferment-y (hetadzgum zhamanaki tiruytum): Aysuhanderdz, differance-y ays erku tarreri sovorakan miakcumy che, ayl aravel naxnakan (skzbnakan) e, qan tarberutyuny ev hetadzgumy arandzin-arandzin: Ayd pattcharov el ayn naxordum e tarberutyan u hetadzgman anjatmany (Derrida Zh., Golos i fenomen: vvedenie v problematiku znakov v fenomenologii Gusserlya // [ per. C. Angl. S. G. Kalinina]. – SPB.: Aleteyya, 1999, st.116):
Ays kargi anhetetutyunnerov ughghaki li en suyn tgeti veronshyal «grqi» anhodabashx phsxvacqnery, qanzi nrancum tarberakeli chen philisophayakan haskacutyunnery, sharahyusakan hamakargy, dzevabanakan u pattcharahetevanqayin miavornery, metody kam metodnery, voroncov arajnordvel e tgety, mi xosqov ayn ameny, inch arnchvum e qnnadatakan kam aveli tchisht: grakanagitakan (layn arumov) teqsti karucmany: Sa e pattchary, vor dranq ynkalvum en vorpes chmarsvac teqster u chen apahovum mtqi (aystegh: hodvacneri) karucman tarrakan kanonnery, ynterneliutyunn u ymbrneliutyuny: Phsxvacqnerov li voch gitakan ays aghbakuyty arzhanacel e naev «Nikol Aghbalyan» mrcanaki: Hetaqrqir e, vor «erevelin» e mijnordel ev inch nkrtumnerov:
e. Suyny «nshanakali erevuyt» e hamarum sosk «Grakanagitakan handesy» (ori patasxanatu mragirn e inqy), qanzi ir angraget phsxvacqnery tpagrvum e miayn aystegh: aranc graqnnutyan, mardkanc achqeric heru: ir anunic araj grelov nax Sergey Sarinyani anuny, hetevabar, vov khamardzakvi aylevs suyni anhodabashx phsxvacqnery chtpagrel: Orinak: « «Asem krkin: Sarinyani mtabanakan (…) aporian e, ur «araj en ynknum» (…) (erbemn) mimyancic anhaty ev hasarakutyuny, (…) bayc chen ushanum… galiqic, (…) krian chi ushanum…??? Aqillesi neti (…) aragatrich slacqic: (…) aprelov naxasteghc tiezerakan ir kyanqy, (…) vorn ir amboghjutyunn uni (miayn ireny) …» (…) («Grak. handes», 2012, ej 40: Yndgc.: N. H.):
Veroberyali aritov tes:
1. a. Zenoni aporian aravel ushadir yntercelu depqum ktesnenq, vor irakanum nra arajadrac xndri eutyuny voch te kriayi tegh hasnelu kam chhasnelu paragan e, inchpes vor qnnadatakan - philisophayakan empirik eqstazi mej yntercoghin molorecnum e suyn grchaky, ayl Aqillesi: kriayin hasnelu ev ancnelu hangamanqy:
b. Zenoni «Aqillesn u krian», inchpes naev «Nety» tarber aporianer en, ev Aqillesn amenevin el net chuner: «aragatrich slacqov»: Xeghatyurel Zenoni hanrahayt aporian ayd kerp, meghm asac, tgitutyun e:
2. a. Sergey Sarinyany «mtabanakan» ??? ayd aporian anhati u hasarakutyan aritov chi asel, ayl groghi: anhat u hasarakutyan liirav andam linelu, qani vor amen anhat che, vor grogh e, bayc amen grogh ANHAT e:
b. Arevmtyan tesabanutyan mej derevs 1960-akan tt. bazmativ andradardzner kan Zenoni haytni aporiayin (tes Delyozi u Gvattarii, Deridayi, Lakani ev verjapes Oqsfordi hamalsarani gitnakanneri haytni ashxatutyunnery), usti ays ushacac «tesaqnnabanakan» ariayi mijocov voch mi nor haytnagorcutyun chi katarel, ayl ughghaki anunner chtalov: vaghuc anti cecvac suyn «gyuty» veragrel e S. Sarinyanin:
3. «Grakanagitakan handesi» veronshyal anhodabashx phsxvacqy li e nman xeghatyurumnerov: (tes H. Movsesin, H. Edoyanin, V. Ephremyanin, T. Tonoyanin, V. Ayvazyanin verabervogh hatvacnery): Artagrutyunner ev imitacianer A. Harutyunyani poeziayi aritov (tes A. Harutyunyan, «Herustapoemner…», E., 2010, ej 547-563 ev «Grak. handes», E., MMXII, ej 68-69):
y. Parzvum e naev, vor suyny voch miayn «mtqery» verartadrel, aylev kardal chgiti, qani vor «Patmutyan patmutyuny verlucutyun e, bayc: masnavor» mitqy imy che, ayl Karl Marqsiny, um anuny nshel em mejberman koghqin: phakagcerum, miazhamanak voch te «Luys - a - Ptuyt», inchpes nshum e suyny, ayl «P.s – D. Memory traces» qnnadatakan hodvacum (tes «Garun», 2012, 9-10):
t. «Uracumn e sa, te Herostratn e artnacel xmbagri eutyan mej» harcy arajadrelov: phordzum e miavorner havaqel Ayvazyani hashvin: «Bnagir ev teqst» -um inchpes naev «Grakanagitakan handes» -um (ZhG, 2012) tpagrvac aghavaghumnery hamarelov «xor lrjutyamb verlucutyun tarber tesankyunneric» : suyny moranum e, vor akademikosic gluxy prcacnelu hamar «Qnnadatakan mtorumner ev grarumner» -um (ej 78) grel er, te Ayvazyann «ankarevor» e hamarel «Gaghtni anuny» essen, ayd pattcharov el chi yndgrkel «Anhenaran u anxarisx: erkri nman» (2007) grqum: Ayninch Ayvazyany veronshyal zhoghovacui tpagrutyan orerin eghel e hivandanocum ev essen ayd yntacqum e grel, ayd pattcharov el ayn durs e mnacel grqic: Isk harcy, te suyn tgety garunakan e, te eghel e sosk garunakanneri manklaviky, inqn e Ayvazyani anunn ogtagorcelov dardzel qnnadatik, te Ayvazyany: irenov grogh, shat vitcheli e, qanzi krkin dimarnum enq aysor grakanutyan mej tirogh aghandavor barqerin: Erevuyt, vor misht el kareli e shrjel dimacini dem: inchpes kamenas: Aysqanic heto inch-or keghc phasteric u mejberumneric e xosum tgety, inch-or sxalner tchanachelu kam chtchanachelu keghc harcer e bardzracnum: krknakioren molorecnelov yntercoghin u miazhamanak moranalov nshel, vor «Garunum» tpagrvac «anqnnadat hodvacikneric» ??? shateri gitakan ghekavary ir nman tgetn e:
zh. Parzvum e: suyny minch ayzhm jric chor e durs ekel tarber xmbagrutyunnerum hamapatasxan mardik unenalu shnorhiv: Na mshtapes teghekacvel e ir phsxvacqneri dem grvac qnnadatakan hodvacneri masin u naxapes kanxel dranc tpagrutyuny: Inchpes asum en, karoghacel e: arel e: Lav e da te vat: miayn Astcun e haytni, bayc suyny dranov chi bavararvum: phordzelov verahskel voghj tpagrakan nyuty: nuynisk hodvacner trcnelu paymanov: Asvaci havastumy 2012 tvakani hulisin «Garun» amsagri xmbagrutyunic derevs chtpagrvac «Dismorfomania» hodvacy trcneln er: U erb zangum em ev asum, te da tpagrakan etikayi xaxtum e, na indz kargi e hravirum, te: petq e tchakatagric goh linem, vor ir nmany barehatchel e yntercel hodvacs u anjatum e heraxosy:
i. Aghavaghel e naev dismorfomania bari bararanayin imasty: «Dismorfomaniya [grech. morphe-forma, mania-bezumie] bred fizicheskogo nedostatka. Razvitiyu dismorfomanii mogut predshestvovat navyazchivie idei fizicheskogo nedostatka. Esli ono na samom dele net, a chelovek pri etom ubezhden v sobstvennom urodstve, xodit po vracham i dazhe operiruetsya u plasticheskix xirurgov, libo zhe vpadaet v anoreksiyu, to tut rech idet o dismorfomanii [bredovoy uroven rasstroystv] [tes Zhmurov V. A., Bolshaya enciklopediya po psixiatrii, 2-oe izd., 2012 g.]» . Hodvacn ushadir yntercoghy lav el kpatkeracni: inchi masin e xosqy: Karcum em, amenevin el petq che vkayakochel «Hin Teben» : (hin-n el mecatarov en grel: N. H.) tgitutyan chtesac ardzani masin «husher» patmelov. ayn azgovi karogh enq patvirel u kangnecnel Erevani qaghaqapetarani dimac: «Grakanagitutyan qanqar ev rahvira Abrahamyan Surik» phoragrutyamb:
H. G.
Cnvum en patasxanner aknkalogh anxusapheli harcer: ardyoq mer portalary ktrvel e naxamardu qarandzavic kam: vorqan el avstraliakan aragavaz jaylami pes vtangi depqum taqcnenq mer gluxy tpherum: vorpes zgushavor, bayc gorsh mi zangvac, ardyoq dardzel enq aynqan qaghaqakirt, vor karogh enq gavary xaghaghutyamb anvanel qaghaq, isk gavaramtutyuny: anteri tchashaki orensdir, ev ardyoq «GT» -um tegh gtac suyn erkxosutyun - hogevarqy qnnadatutyan inqnaspanutyan lavaguyn orinak che: Kam: hnaravor e grakan - qnnadatakan banavetchi qoghi nerqo tpagrel 1937-akannerin harir matnagrer: chkoghmnoroshvelov nuynisk erkxosutyun e da, te zarancanq: menaxosakan tprtocnerov: Parzvum e: hnaravor e, vorovhetev qarandzavn el e mery, kolxozn el e mery, kolektiv angitakcutyunn el e mery, «azatutyunn» el e mery u bolori… Usti partavor em gitakan elitayin ughghel hetevyal harcy. vov e suyn baxtaxndir tgety, vor angragitutyan, hogebanakan u mardkayin nman axtacin tvyalnerov phordzum e iren veragrel voroshoghi kam gnahatoghi kargavitchakner: sahmanelu «grakan ardi zargacman mitumnery ev ughghutyunnery» u aghavaghelu grakanutyan u qnnadatutyan demqy (Astvac heru pahi «ereveli» baxtagushaknerc u akademiakan mijakutyunneri agresiayic), ev verjapes, inch xeghkatakutyun e sa:

Sergey Sarinyani «Andradardz» hodvaci aritov.

Haraberutyunneri bazmakerputyuny dzevavorvum e zugaher tarber irakanutyunneri hnaravor bolor hatumnerum, tepet XX daraverji ev XXI daraskzbi bnagitakan u humanitar imacutyunneri yndhanur druytnery hangum en mtacoghutyan anhatakan — arandznakerp — yurorinak dzeveri universalacmany ev meknabanvum vorpes inqnin goyutyun: Ays hamateqstum irakananum en mi sharq gorcyntacner, voronq genetikoren bxum en nra hetevanqneric: erevutacnelov korusyal tiezerqi ev ayn chgtnelu melamaghdzic cnvac dramatik vitchakneri anyndhat veraprman mitumy:

Taracutyunn yndunak e pahpanel ir mej vochinchy. erbemn ayn haytnabervum e subyekti anhangstutyan dzevov: miavorelov nra anhatakanutyan zusp kam anzusp koghmery: Erevuyti erkbeverutyuny, sakayn, verjinis nersum nuynpes steghcum e taracutyan zgacumy, vortegh nerkrvogh hnaravor bolor zgacoghutyunneri mijocov (or: erevakayakan amenakaroghutyan) veranum e sahmany Es-i u Ger-egoyi mijev: hascnelov inchpes nerqin, aynpes el artaqin iroghutyunneri xeghatyurmany: U qani vor mardkayin hogebanutyunn u nra zargacumn arka en kyanqi u mahvan bnazdneri mijev, artaqin u nerqin irakanutyunneri hatuytum, hetevabar kecutyan bnazdayin kerpi bavararumy, vorpes erosi artahaytutyun, amrapndum e havaty nra patkeri handep ev tulacnum mahvan bnazdic sparnacogh vtangy ev Ger-egon: Ays depqum nranc kroghnery sksum en bacahaytel irenc anhatakanutyan cicaghaharuyc koghmery u naev ayn (orqan el sqoghen), vor chen tirapetum uzhin, qani vor anyndhat veraprum en nuyn brikolazhy u gorcarum ayn vorpes sahman tarber mardkanc nkatmamb:

Ayspisi mtacumneri arity LGhH groghneri miutyan «Eghici luys» (2011, N 1-2) tertukum (miayn tertukum karogh en tpagrel banasteghcutyunner Xulio Kortasari «Xoseq, duq uneq ereq rope» zhoghovacuic: chnshelov targmanchi anuny ev aghbyury: Tes «Eghici luys», 2010, N11) ev apa: «Grakan tert» -um (2012, N 1-5, vorosh havelumnerov) akademikos Sergey Sarinyani tpagrac «Andradardz» xoragrov qnnadatakan motavor-a-pesutyunn e, vori heghinaky qnna-tesa-patmakan patranq steghcelov, aynuamenayniv, aseliqy toghel e xagh-polemikayi tiruytum: Ardyunqum stacvel e yurorinak «ptuyt my qnnadatutyan tagherun mej», vory sakayn chi havaknum gitakan lurj andradardz kochvelun, qani vor akademikosy chi hatel erevuytnery makeresaynutyamb nshagrelu sahmany:

Ays depqum Nicshei mitqy, te dasakanutyany harogh philisophanery (aystegh: grakanagetnery), vovqer arajadrum en miayn gaghapharner, bayc chen hushum dranc iragorcman eghanaknery, hishecnum en Vodisevsi ughekicnerin: xcanvac akanjnerov. «ovqer chlsecin ergy kyanqi: irenc steghcac ashxarhic ayn koghm u karcecin, te amen mi erg sirenneri ergn e miayn» (Nicshe, «Zvart gitutyun»), darnum e aravel qan ardiakan: Hetevabar ev vstahutyuny, te ashxarhy miayn mek goyadzev uni, hatkapes ayn, vorn apahovum e tvyal subyekti goyutyuny (ov aydqan vstah e), darnum e arnvazn anhetetutyun: Erevuyt, vor chaphazanc karevor e aysor qnnadatutyan (layn arumov: grakanagitutyan) qaghaqakanutyan tesankyunic, qanzi xndirn ays paragayum gitakan npatakaharmarutyunn e, inqna — npatak ayn xohamtutyuny, vorn ir nerqin tiruytum amphophum e hodvaci anuzh — ankarogh — utyuny, usti ayn kareli e bnutagrel naev subyektiv bambasanq kam ankap krakahert ezrerov:

Ays hamateqstum bnagrayin bolor phoxarutyunnery dzerq en berum parodik hatkanishner: hegnakan erangov shrjvelov heghinaki dem, qanzi «Andradardzum» Varuzhan Ayvazyani «Hamematakan kensagrutyunner» vepi xoragiry dardzel e «Anavart kensagrutyunner», Violet Grigoryani xmbagrutyamb luys tesnogh «Inqnagiry»: «Inqnutyun», Naira Hambardzumyani «Es bar em dardzel» banasteghcutyunneri zhoghovacun: «Es bar em voronum»: Arka en naev artasanutyan u grutyan anhamapatasxanutyamb ogtagorcvac bazmativ barer, inchpes: Haydegery: Heydeger (germaneren, angleren, ruseren teqsterum bac vankum artasanvum ev grvum e [ i ] — [ˈmaɐ̯tiːn ˈhaɪdɛɡɐ]) Syoren Kirkegory: [ˈsœːɐn ˈkʰiɐ̯kəˌɡ̊ɒˀ] Syuren Kirkegor, Rolan Bartn yndhanrapes grvac e ughghagrakan sxalov: Bart, polit-art-y: poilit-art, Ur-fashizmy: Uo-fashizm (tés Umberto Eko, Pyat esse na temi etiki, S-P symposium, 2007 st. 49-81 kam: «Aktual arvest», 2008, tiv 6, ej 7-10), Nazaret Karoyany: Nazaret Karsyan, Vahan Teryani «Hogevor Hayastany»: «Hogevor hayreniq» ev ayspes sharunak….: Kan mtqer, voronq yndhanrapes xeghvac en. inchpes: «patkeravor ays xosqerum vochinch nor gaghaphar chka» ??? (guce: voch mi, aylapes naxadasutyuny stacvum e arevmtahayeren, N.H.), kam: «…inchi pattcharnery kareli e veragrel patmakan tchakatagrin, mshakutayin ktrvacutyany, ekeghecu angraget dzevuytin, qaghaqayin anazatutyany…. ??? (guce: qaghaqakan)» kam: «hayreniqy ver e amen kargi fizikakan, ashxarhagrakan, azgayin u hogevor-mshakutayin atributneric arandzin vercrac ??? ev henc dranc yndhanrutyan mej e miavorvum etnikakan mi hamaparphak yndhanrutyun ???»:

Zhamanakakic hogebanutyunn ays erevuytn anvanum e memory traces (hishoghutyan hetqer): kapvac subyekti: zhamanaki u taracutyan mej ararkanern u erevuytnery zhamanakavorapes hishelu mexanizmneri gorconin: «Andradardz» -um subyektnern u xndraharuyc harcery shat en u tarber, ayd pattcharov el kandradarnam miayn indz hetaqrqrogh erevuytnerin u harcerin:

1809 tvakani mart amsin ir tghayi usucchin: Fridrix Vilhelm Rimerin, grac mi namakum ****en hogebanakan harcadrum e katarum: «Inchu en shat u shat mardik mec anhangstutyamb yndunum nor andzi haytnvely», ev inqn el anverapahoren patasxanum e ir harcin. «orovhetev tvyal andzy ushadrutyun e hravirum ayn hatkanishnerin kam erevuytnerin, vor nranq chunen kam chen nkatel kam el verjinis mijocov bacahaytum en irenc gaghtni vat voraknery: Te meky, ev te myusy nranc srtov chen: Ev ete noreky hamest e u kirt, nran atum en vomanq, u mi kerp handurzhum en myusnery, isk ete na inqnavstah e ev inqnuruyn, nran atum en bolory» (tes Iogann Volfgang Gete, ‟Pesma, dnevniki", AST, 1998): Ays ameni mej, karcum em, mi ban hastatapes parz e: urishi, otari nerkayutyuny voreve klanum inqnin vtang e, hatkapes, erb na ayl e ashxarhayacqov, ymbrnumnerov, inqnutyan gitakcutyamb:

Inqnapashtpanutyan mexanizmnery sovorabar carayum en nerqin angitakcakan konfliktneri pahpanmany: hanun mez haytni hogekan havasarakshrutyan: Sranum en nranc drakan u karucoghakan gorcaruytnery: Ete aydpisi pashtpanutyunnery chen ognum, gorcarvum en zgayakan zenqery, voronq hatchax darnum en hogeterapiayi ararka: Bolor ayd gorconnern angitakcakan en, sakayn nranc himqum steghcvum en naxapasharumner, voronq ahreli phophoxutyunneri en entarkum mardu nerashxarhy: socialakan, mshakutayin, gitakan ev ayl volortnerum darnalov vtangavor: Ete nkatelu linenq, apa hzor kurtizanakan dixotomiayi zhamanakneric derevs hogebannery anhusoren tapharum en tektonikakan ays averaki: hogebanutyan philisophayutyan xorqerum: erbemn-erbemn hatvelov voreve harcum:

Ays arumov hetaqrqrasharzh e hetevyal parberutyuny. «Inqnin ushagrav en Ayvazyani hodvaci ardzaganqnery, hatkapes, qnnadatutyan asparezum indz anhayt Naira Hambardzumyan anunov meki storagrutyamb tpagrvac «Luys-A-Ptuyt» hanelukayin vernagrov hodvacy, vory sakayn Varuzhani hodvaci parz imitacian e, qan meknutyan phordz…, — grum e akademikosy: hasnelov zgayakan-empirik ansahmanutyan, vory miazhamanak vaxn e: anverj bac taracutyan arjev, qanzi voch voqi hamar gaghtniq che, vor patmutyan patmutyuny verlucutyun e, bayc: masnavor: Usti vorpes masnavor andz akademikosy karogh er qnnadatutyan etikan hascnel kencaghagoyutyan (anhayt-haytni), vori sharzharitn empirik kirqn e kam Shanti haytni dramayi empirik yntercumy: handzin tchermakazgest Hannayi, bayc vorpes akademiakan subyekt na karogh er ver kangnel mahkanacuakan gaytakghutyunneric: akademiakanutyuny chmghelov depi akademizm, qanzi cankacac izm ir mej i skzbane krum e tvyal erevuyti ankanxakal-anpharunak vaxtchany:

I verjo iroghutyunnery:

a. «Hrachya Atcharyan» hamalsaranum akademikosy varel e hay grakanutyan ambiony, vortegh ut tari sharunak dasaxosel e naev Naira Hambardzumyany
b. 2003 tvakanin akademikosy naxagahum er HH GAA grakanutyan instituti masnagitakan ayn xorhurdy, vortegh banasirakan gitutyunneri teknacui gitakan astitchan e shnorhvel Naira Hambardzumyanin:
g. na eghel e Naira Hambardzumyani: 2004 tvakanin luys tesac «Kanach karetner» banasteghcutyunneri zhoghovacui xmbagiry, anzhxteli en:
Inch verabervum e imitaciayi xndrin, apa hamapatasxan giteliqner unecogh yntercoghy shat hangist karogh e erku hodvacn el yntercel u gnahatel, voch voqic dranq taqcvac chen (tes «Grakan tert», 2009, tiv 39, ej 3 ev «Grakan tert», 2010, tiv 17, ej 3), qanzi suyn meghadranqy yndameny anhimn heryuranq e: Ev i verjo, imitaciayi lavaguyn orinak kam ayspes kochvac, nerqin plagiat che ardyoq hetevyal parberutyuny akademikosi katarmamb:
tes ev hmmt.
• «Chpetq e moranal, vor verjin tarineri yntacqum hay irakanutyan mej cagel e mi nor inteligencia, mi nor serund, vorin otar che evropakan kulturan, gone ir xoshor gcerov, vor evropakan krtutyun stacac, evropacu kyanqov aprac, darnum e hayreniq ev bnakanabar goh che mnum ir hayreniqum tirogh kargeric u haskacoghutyunneric… Asum em ayd bolor ararkutyunnery chaphazanc miamit en ev hin: Hay kgheri dery mer patmutyan mej eghel e shat xoshor ev shat korstaber, averich yst amenayni… Patmutyan mej chaphazanc mec der e veragrvum mer kgherin, ibr azgi lusavorutyan ev hogekan — kulturakan pahanjnery hogacogh zhrajan mi dasi… Qani vor kghery der uni zhoghovrdakan dprocum, misht petq e kaskacov ev erkyughov verabervem depi ayd dprocy… seminaristakan, tiracuakan mtacoghutyuny ev inqy: kghery, vor minchev ayzhm hovanavorum u snum e ayd seminarizmy…» (Vahan Teryan, Erker, Haypethrat, E., 1956, ej 490-497):
• «…ori ashxarhayacqy dzevavorvel e evropakan kulturayi azdecutyamb ev hamenayndeps kyanqy ditum e voch te negh-azgayin hayecaketic, ayl yndhanur-mardkayin idealneri chaphanishov… Dproc ev ekegheci, azgayin mtavorakanutyun ev kgher: aha ayn uzhery, voronq karchac hnameni kurqerin, hay hasarakakan mtqi u grakanutyan mtnolorty mtagnum en tiracuakan, sahmanaphak mtacoghutyamb, makeresayin, inqnabav seminarizmov» (S. Sarinyan, Hay grakanutyan erku dary, Sovet. grogh, 1988, h. 1, ej 399):
Petq e xostovanel, vor Vahan Teryani «Hogevor Hayastan» hodvaci u namakneri yntranu verasharadranqy (tes ev hmmt. S. Sarinyan, Hay grakanutyan erku dary, Sovet. grogh, 1988, h. 1, ej 395-409) sovetakan grakanagitutyan bacarik nmushneric e, qanzi akademikosin tvacel e, te yntercoghy unak che ynkalelu «Hogevor Hayastan» -ii tesutyuny, u inqy piti verapatmi duyny ir barerov:
U qani vor xosq gnac imitaciayic, apa arajarkum em zugaher yntercel naev (tes ev hmmt. Nikolay Berdyaev, Russkaya ideya, 1946, Izd. AST, (erkrord ev errord hrat. 2007, 2009) ashxatutyuny, inchpes naev «Inqnutyun» (Hum. hetazotutyunneri haykakan kentron, 1995, E., «Kamar» hrat.) parberakany: ushadrutyan kentronum pahelov nranum arka hodvacneri harcadrumnery, aynuhetev akademikosi «Hay gaghapharabanutyun» (E., «Zangak-97», 1998) usumnasirutyuny (hetagayum grqi xoragiry phoxvel e: «Hayoc azgayin gaghapharabanutyun», E., «Zangak-97», 2005, 328 ej):
Ushagrav e naev, vor «amen inch artacolvac e amen inchum», «I skzbane er Bann», Logos, Alqimia» (tiv 1, ej 5) haskacutyunnern «aylevs areghcvacner chen» akademikosi hamar, qani vor dranq «arcarcel u verarcarcel en bazum imastaserner», isk aha luysi u nra ptuyti gaghaphary mnacel e haneluk: « «Luys-A-Ptuyt» hanelukayin vernagrov hodvacy» (nuyn teghum, S. S.):
Stacvum e: ashxarhy voch miayn korcrel e imasty, aylev ayspes avartvum e animastutyan shrjany, isk racionalizmy mer orerum, gorcelov sosk andznakan npatakaharmarutyan dirqeric, i verjo, carayum e annpatak u arhestakan ashxarhasteghcmany: artagrum e — chi artagrum, hetevabar tagnapy, vor haytnabervum e nerqin obyekti ev egoyi nuynakanutyan mijocov, dzerq e berum hetapndman vorak veronshyal erku nerqin: bacaka u nerka obyektneri mijev, vori sahmannery jnjvum en ir: akademikosi artagrutyan (plagiati) phastov:
tes ev hmmt.
• «Raffun kam Proshyanin u Aghayanin — Sologubic u Hamsunic hogebanoren darer en bazhanum, minchder Sologubn sksel e ir grakan kyanqy Raffu kendanutyan zhamanak ev Aghayani u Proshyani orov artadrel e ir lavaguyn steghcagorcutyunnery» (V. Teryan, Erker, Haypethrat., E., 1956, ej 490):
• «Raffun ev Proshyanin Sologubic u Hamsunic hogebanoren darer en bazhanum, minchder Sologubn sksel e ir grakan kyanqy Raffu kendanutyan zhamanak ev Aghayani u Proshyani orov artadrel e ir lavaguyn steghcagorcutyunnery» (S. Sarinyan, Hayoc grakanutyan erku dary, h. 1, 1988, ej 398):
• «Hayreniqi ergy hnchel e mezanum aravel kam pakas uzhegh: Eghisheic ev Xorenacuc minchev mer orery… gunavorel mer inteligenciayi mitqn u erevakayutyuny darer sharunak» (V. Teryan, Erker, Haypet hrat., E., 1956, ej 490):
• «Hayreniqi ergy hnchel e aravel kam pakas uzhegh: Eghisheic ev Xorenacuc minchev mer orery… darer sharunak gunavorel mer mtavorakanutyan…» (S. Sarinyan, Hayoc grakanutyan erku dary, h. 1, 1988, ej 398):
Ayd vaxy kazmaqandman azdaki mijocov amrapndvum e obyekti mej, kam aveli tchisht, veraprvum vorpes vax: «karavarman chtrvogh obyekti arjev» (Melanie Klein, «Notes on some schizoid mechanisms», 1952, p. 292-320), usti hogu ev marmni mijev arka haraberutyuny, baci hogebanakany, dzerq e berum naev philisophayakan sheshtadrum ev harabervum gaghapharneri volortin:
Vaghuc avartvel e havataqnnutyan hzor darashrjany, sakayn havaty sharunakum e harabervel vogu vtangavor, bayc qaghcr gaytakghutyunnerin: Grakanutyan patmutyan u philisophayutyan shgharshov parurvac suyn verapruknery (tes «Grakan tert», 2012, tiv 1-5), dzerq berelov tavtologik hatkanishner, yntercoghin ughghordum en depi mijnadaryan mtacelakerpy: zugadrakan shghtayi mijocov steghcelov aravelapes grakan-patmakan utopia, qan qnnadatutyun-andradardz: Tepet, i verjo, veronshyaly sosk paymanakanutyun e: kaxvac ayn yndunogh kam chyndunogh yntercoghic (patrastvacutyan xndiry nkati unem), um mijocov patahakanutyuny darnum e nshanakali kam hakaraky.
tes ev hmmt.
• «Paronyani artahaytutyamb: covi vra dziarshav e anum, camaqi vra: navarkutyun» (S. Sarinyan, Hayoc grakanutyan erku dary, h. 4, 2004, ej 605):
• «Paronyani artahaytutyamb: covi vra dziarshav e anum, camaqi vra: navarkutyun» («Grakan tert», 2012, 27 hunvari, ej 2): (I dep, suyn artahaytutyuny akademikosi gyuty che, ayl Aramayis Karapetyani (teBs «Grakanagitakan psixostazia» hodvacy, 1969), vorum na qnnadatel e ynker Sarinyani «Haykakan romantizm» ashxatanqy):
• «…es bardzr em gnahatum Hakob Movsesi voronogh mitqy, nori zgacoghutyunn u bardzr chaphanishnery…» («Grakan tert», 1992, 6 marti, ej 3):
• «es gnahatum em Varuzhan Ayvazyani grakan taghandy ev voronumi hakvac nra erkeri mtavor larumnery…» («Grakan tert», 2012, 10 phetrvari, ej 2):
• «Chxoselov arden Platoni, Adornoyi, Malarmei, Elioti, Yakobsoni, Epshteyni, Russoyi, Markesi, Bloki, Herakliti, Shellingi, Kanti, Mandelshtami, Dantei, Viyoni, Klodeli, Zhan Persii, Tagori ev bazum ayl anunneri masin: Ev akama harc e cagum: verjapes inch gavarakan cucamolutyun e sa…»: («Grakan tert», 1989, 21 hulisi, ej 2-4):
• «…vkayakochum e anunner: Dionisios Aeropageci, Palievski, Ploton, Philon Aleqsandraci, Hegel, Shelling, Yakovlev, Platon, Kant, Lui Aragon, Aristotel, Sokrat, Yamblex, Porfyur, Lotman, Kete Hamburger, Max, Klement Aleqsandraci… hodvaci heghinaky qnnadatutyan gitutyuny xeghatyurum e gavaramtutyamb….» («Grakan tert», 2012, 10 phetrvari, ej 2):

«Patmutyunn arajin angam krknvum e vorpes voghbergutyun, - asum er Karl Marqsy, - erkrord angam: vorpes fars»: «Andradardz» -y, inchpes cuyc e talis qnnadatutyan patmutyuny (tes mejberumneri tvakannery), ays el vorerord angam, voch miayn krknvum e, aylev parodiayi e entarkum inqn iren: Arajarkum em yntercel hetevyal hodvacnery: («Grakan tert», 1989, 21 hulisi, ej 2-4: «Grakan tert», 1992, 6 marti, ej 3: S. Sarinyan, Hayoc grakanutyan erku dary, h. 4, 2004, ej 605, nuyny: 1969t.: «Grakan tert», 2012, tiv 1-5, ej 2-3:) u hamozvel, vor ays depqum hay grakanutyan patmutyuny nuynisk qsan tarin mek angam zargacman u arajyntaci voch mi eakan phophoxutyun chi krel (sksac 1969 tvakanic), ev ete phoxenq suyn hodvacneri herosneri anunnery, apa ktesnenq, vor kaghapary, karucman eghanaky u nuynisk shat u shat artahaytutyunner u dzevakerpumner, yndhup minchev verjin toghi harcadrumy: «Bayc minchev erb ev minchev ur…», nuynn en:
Krknutyan phordzy masamb drvateli hatkanish e dprocahasak ashakerti hamar, sakayn gitutyan mej ayn mshtapes veratchum e krknabanutyan (tavtologiayi): steghcelov sharzhman ansharzhutyuny, vor nuyn kangarn e, nuyn tchahitchy, yurorinak dardz i shrjans yur: totalitaristakan armatneric snvogh: Vochinch, baci terahavatutyunic, ayspisi ditarkumnery chen karogh arajacnel, qani vor arajyntaci ymbrnmany hakadrvum en sephakan droshmanishov mifery, voronc steghcman kamayakanutyan astitchany depi absurdy mitogh kollazh e hishecnum, ev arka taratip sxalnery anyndhat krknvelu hatkutyun en dzerq berum: Sakayn karces akademikosi hamar aynqan el karevor che, te steghcvoghy mif e, ev grakanutyan patmutyunn arnchvum e goyutyan (aystegh naev: erevuyti) ankatarutyamb himnavor ays metaforin:
Mtavor kargapahutyuny, kargukanonin hetevely, depi vorn ughghordum e akademikosy, isk nranic araj, shat vaghuc ayd arel e Dekarty (mi erevuyty bxecnel myusic, qanzi arandznabar chi karogh goyutyun unenal voreve tchshmartutyun, vorn anhasaneli lini ev aynqan gaghtni, vor hnaravor chlini bacahaytel), kareli e ditarkel vorpes racionalizmi darashrjanic asdin tapharogh urvakan, qanzi XX daraverji ev XXI daraskzbi philisophayutyan ev arhasarak arvesti bolor bnagavarnerum bardzradzaynvum en hatkapes racionalizmi tchgnazhami u qaosi masin, voronc mijev tchshmartutyan bacardzakutyunn ir dirqery zijum e haraberakanutyany:
Erevuyt, vory hishecnum e angliaci grogh, 2011t. buqeri mrcanakakir Julian Patrik Barnsi «Ashxarhi patmutyuny 10 1/2 gluxnerum» vepi tchamphordutyun-aghety: nav-tapani ughevorutyan hatacakan, dipvacayin nkaragrutyuny, vori zhamanak tapany veracvum e loghacogh zndani: nranum gtnvoghneri hamar: Isk irakanutyuny goyutyan qaosn e hogebuzhakan hivandanocum, Qeti xelagarutyan proyekcian, vor naev ashxarhinn e. «Aghety dardzel e arvest, - grum e Barnsy, - ev hnaravor e, glxavor imasty henc dranum e, aravel evs, erb Zherikoyi ktavi shrjanakum hangrvanel e hin canots: phaytojily» (‟A History of the World in 10 1/2 Chapters" (1989, targm. anglerenic: N. H.):
Ardyoq grakanutyan patmutyunn ays paragayum chi darnum yndameny qaosum tapharogh patkerneri u dzayneri empirik ardzaganq, vory heto anhetanum e grakan yntacqi masin hnacac datoghutyunneri u nkatumneri xorxoratnerum: i cuyc dnelov dzgtumy: tramabanakan tchshgrtutyamb steghcel antramabanakan (hyus-a-ban-akan) irakanutyun:
Glxavor npatakov tarvacutyuny: otarel irenic phoqrishate vtang nershnchogh yuraqanchyur subyekti (hanun tchermakazgest Hannayi), xangarel e akademikosin: steghcel arancqayin karuyc: teghi talov aravelapes komikakan u voghbergakan efektnerin («Grakan tertum», 2012, N 1-5): Erevuyty, karcum em, patkeravor klini Barnsi astghagnac herosi: Sphayq Tehleri (ov Ararati gagatin havatavor erandov voronum er Noyan Tapani hetqery: (glux 6-9) havastelov, vor gitakan arajyntacy anzor e hakadrvel naxapasharumnerin) mi naxadasutyamb. «Menq hamaroren sharunakum enq ditel patmutyuny vorpes salonayin dimankarneri ev zruycneri sharq, vori masnakicnery tetevoren artnanum en mer mtapatkernerum ev hishecnum aravelapes qaosayin kolazh» (targm. anglerenic: N. H.):
Mify, vor matucvum e suyn «Andradardz» -um irakanutyan phoxaren, vaghuc apakarucvel u artaqsvel e mardkutyan kolektiv hishoghutyan tiruytic ev aylevs chi karogh naxanshel voreve meki tchanaparhy, aravel evs: keghtotel kensagrutyuny, qanzi totalitar hasarakargi phluzmany zugyntac, phoxvel e naev verabermunqy suyn erevuyti nkatmamb: nergorcelu arumov: Chem zhxtum naev druyty, te voch voq chi karogh kanxatesel phophoxutyunnery ymbrnman ev phordzi bevernerum, voroncum mify eghel u mnum e gorcogh uzh: Usti petq e entadrel nman phoxakerpumneri hnaravorutyuny ev nkatel, vor verjins hnaravor e ayn depqum, erb gitakanutyuny veracvum e miakoghmani klani: korcnelov uzhy, isk nra xndraharuyc u xoceli koghmery aravel qan erbeq: tesaneli:
H.G.
Suyn hodvacy 2011 tvakanin chtpagrelu pattchary akademikosi tghayi mahn er, sakayn aysor haskanum em u xostovanum, vor hamatarac baroyakan arzhezrkman mitumneri mej aydpisi harceri shurj xorheln u qayl katarely miangamayn anteghi er, nuynisk anlurj, inchi havastumy 2011-i «Eghici luysi» nuyn «Andradardzi» (orosh lracumnerov) artatputyunn er 2012-in «Grakan tertum»:
Havelvac I
Te inchu e mardkutyuny moracel Veracnndi zhamanakashrjani trichqneri masin u ynkghmvel XX — XXI dareri qaosum, ushadir yntercoghn ayd harci patasxany kgtni suyn «Andradardzi» epistolyar-namakayin vogu mej, qanzi naxnakan eutyunneri dern anchapheli e taracutyan inch-inch keteri mijev, nranq chen arandznanum vayrkyani tevoghutyamb ev chunen nyuti zangvaci ketayin kshiry: Ays aritov ushagrav en hodvaci hetevyal mtqery:
I.
«Grakanaget Suren Abrahamyany phordzec hermenevtik verlucutyamb vercanel groghi geghagitakan kodagrumnery «Tchantchi amisy» ev «Anavart ??? kensagrutyunner» (yndgcumy: N. H.) erkerum, sakayn grakan shrjannerin aydpes el hasu cheghav ayvazyanakan bnagri meknutyan banadzevy: Ev bnagirn er bard, ev qnnadati lezun: Terevs kariq er zgacvum groghi inqnabacahaytmany» ???», — grum e akademikosy (yndgcumnery: N. H., tiv 1, ej 5):
Hstak e, vor xosqy Abrahamyani «Hermenevtikakan shrjanak kam semantikakan apakarucum» (2008), «Tchakatagir ev teqst kam lezu ev tchanachoghutyun» (2007), «Araspelnery erbeq avartun chen…» (1998) hodvacneri masin e, ev te inch terutyunner, antuylatreli sheghumner, harmarecumner, artagrutyunner kam artaqin plagiati phaster kan ayd hodvacnerum, dranc masin kxosem ayl aritov, ays depqum indz hetaqrqroghy veroberyal mtqi tramabanakan antinomian e, vor miangamic achqi e zarnum ev voric bxum e hetevyal harcy: tekuz qnnadatakan parz lezvov, bayc Abrahamyann inchpes k- «inqnabacahayter» Ayvazyanin, ete da chaner Ayvazyann inqy, hakarak depqum, Abrahamyani katarmamb ayn kynkalver vorpes masin, qani vor suyn ezry ays hamateqstum chi gitakcvum vorpes inqnutyan bacahaytum, usti indz mnum e miayn gushakel: guce anhrazhesht er anjat bararmatnerov grel bardutyuny, inchpes: inqnutyan bacahaytmany, kam Ayvazyani: vorpes groghi inqnutyan bacahaytmany: (Ayn tpavorutyunn e, te S. Abrahamyanin vstahvel e hay graqnnadatutyan erevakayakan Don Korleonei dery (estafetayi phoxancumy nkati unem), bayc merorya Dony teracel e ir gorcerum: xtchtchvelov arevmtasiciliakan originali u haykakan qnnadatutyan ezhanagin patenti mijev): Ete nuynisk antesenq veronshyaly, apa groghi inqnabacahaytum ezri ogtagorcumy akademikosi koghmic ays hamateqstum («Ev bnagirn er bard, ev qnnadati lezun: Terevs kariq er zgacvum groghi inqnabacahaytmany» ??? (yndgcumnery: N. H.) ), (tiv 1, ej 5) chi ditvum ardyoq «empirikoren hakasakan» u vorpes «grakan erevuyti makeresayin» ymbrnum ev chi ynkalvum vorpes «masin» …
Ays aritov (masin — y nkati unem) ushagrav e 2008 tvakanin Suren Abrahamyani: «Grakan tertum» tpagrac «Sevakagitutyan ardi harcer kam banasteghcutyan gitutyuny» hodvacy: S. Sarinyani «Paruyr Sevak. banasteghcutyan gitutyuny» (E., 2006) grqi aritov, vorum teghataraph qcnanqi ev mi sharq ayl phrkararakan ashxatanqneri het Abrahamyany lusabanum e naev akademikosi: qnnadatutyan nkatmamb unecac «dirqavorumy» (bary S. A — inn e): «… voch te i hetchuks, vor parzamit kliner nman grakanageti hamar, ayl: sevakagitutyan yntacqy yndgrkelu te zhxtman ev te tchgnazhami, te hastatman amboghjutyan ev herankari handznarutyuny krelu imastov»: (tiv 15, ej 4) mejberum katarelov akademikosi hamanun grqic ev tesaneli dardznelov grakan qnnadatutyan u grakan erki verlucutyan handep nra verabermunqy. «Voch te verlucum en banasteghcutyuny, ayl grum en banasteghci masin, isk «masiny» gitutyun che» (GT, ej 3):
Miamit kliner mtacel, vor akademikosn ays ditarkumnery katarel e miayn u miayn Paruyr Sevaki poeziayi aritov, manavand, erb hajord parberutyamb Abrahamyany havastum e im entadrutyuny. «Aha, inchpes tesnum enq, Sarinyani bnutagrac axtanshannery ughghvac en qnnadatutyany, sakayn qnnadatutyuny empirikoren hakasakan e u zhxtogh, grakan erevuyti makeresayin ymbrnum uni» («Grakan tert», 2008, tiv 15, ej 4):
Verohishyalum, baci tramabanakan antinomian, aknerev e naev suyn imitacian. tes ev hmmt:
• «Voch te verlucum en banasteghcutyuny, ayl grum en banasteghci masin, isk «masiny» gitutyun che»: (Sergey Sarinyan, Paruyr Sevak. banasteghcutyan gitutyuny, E., 2006, ej 3)
• «… kardum es hodvacy ev voch mi patkeracum ches stanum nyuti masin, ayl miayn yndhanur datoghutyunner u makeresayin gnahatakan: Aysinqn voch te verlucum en vepy, ayl grum en vepi masin: Isk inchpes Matevosyann er asum: «masiny grakanutyun che» ev voch el gitutyun» (tes «Hay grakanutyan erku dary», // «I hetchuks», h. 5, 2009, ej 533): (Yndgcumnery: N. H.):
Hetevabar cnvum e mitqy, te:
a. S. Abrahamyann anteghyak e hetevyalin: «Voch te verlucum en banasteghcutyuny, ayl grum en banasteghci masin, isk «masiny» gitutyun che», aghbyurin, ev, vor akademikosy imitaciayi e entarkel Hrant Matevosyani xosqery, ayd pattcharov el Abrahamyany Hrant Matevosyani datoghutyunnery veragrum e akademikosin (suyny mejberum e «I hetchuks» hushagrutyan xmbagrvac u hamalrvac tarberakic (tes «Hay grakanutyan erku dary», h. 5, 2009, ej 533), qani vor husheri naxord grqum (2006) krkin bacakayum en chakertnery) ), vory guce 2009-in chi veryntercel S. Abrahamyany kam yntercel e miayn iren hetaqrqrogh masery…):
b. S. Abrahamyani «GT» -i nuyn hamari hghumy Sergey Sarinyani «Paruyr Sevak. banasteghcutyan gitutyuny» grqic e (E., 2006, ej 3), usti avelord e nshel, vor akademikosy chi hghel Hrant Matevosyani hodvacy naev aystegh:
g. Bavakan hajogh imitacia e, u qani vor yst S. Abrahamyani verjin kanxoroshumneri: imitacian nerqin plagiati var apacuyc e, indz mnum e miayn kaxman keter sharel…
II.
Hetevyal nkatumy: «Votchy ka, bayc nra geghagitakan banadzevn e anavart u chdzevavorvac ???, aravel evs norararutyuny anhaskanaliutyamb imastavorely, vorn inqnin absurd e» ??? («Eghici luys», 2011, tiv 1, ej 5): Ayvazyani vepic bolorovin anteghyak yntercoghin guce ev hamozich tva, sakayn, erb kazmaqandum es nuyn naxadasutyuny, dimarnum es tramabanakan argelqneri, inchpes: «…nra geghagitakan banadzevn e anavart u chdzevavorvac…», «chdzevavorvac» -y erevuytn e, vori gaghaphary ka, bayc derevs goyutyun chuni», yntacqi mej che, «anavart» -y: goyutyun unecogh, sakayn vaxtchanaketin chhasac erevuyt, usti cagum e hetevyal harcy: «anavart», te «chdzevavorvac», kam inch e nshanakum: «norararutyuny anhaskanaliutyamb imastavorely» ???, ete mi erevuyt anhaskanali e, apa inchpes ayn kimastavores, ayn el: norararutyamb, stacvum e: ays nkatumn e inqnin absurd:
III.
Aravel hetaqrasharzh e hajord parberutyuny: «Xndiry Varuzhan Ayvazyani paragan che ???, ayl grakan hayacqnerum nkateli dardzac mtavor ankargapahutyuny ???, nerqin azatutyuny mtahayac tesabanutyan ???, vory voch patmutyun e tchanachum, voch tramabanutyun, ayl taracutyan mej degerogh phuch kam lecun bareri chpattcharabanvac u anmekneli bandagushanq e» («Eghici luys», 2011, tiv 1, ej 5): Bayc che vor mi qani naxadasutyun ver mer akademikosy grum e: «Im ynkalmamb miangamayn gravich e vepi philisophayakan gaghaphary (idean), etnikakan naxaskzbi yntrutyuny: banavor-banahyusakan, te gravor: Hiravi tiezerakan naxaskizb, vor ughghutyun e talis tvyal etnosi patmutyany: Aystegh ev norararutyun ka, ev votchi anhatakanutyun….» («Eghici luys», 2011, tiv 1, ej 5):

Qich te shat tramabanogh yntercoghy hargarzhan akademikosin harc kughghi: «mtavor ankargapahutyamb» (myus mitqy lriv absurd e: «nerqin azatutyuny mtahayac tesabanutyan» ??? (erevi cankacel e gitakan banasteghcutyun grel, N.H.) ), vory «och patmutyun e tchanachum, voch tramabanutyun», groghy inchpes khasni vepi «philisophayakan gaghapharin» (ideayin) kam «etnikakan naxaskzbi» yntrutyany: «banavor-banahyusakan, te gravor» harcadrmamb kam: «tiezerakan naxaskizbin» ughghutyun tvogh «tvyal etnosi patmutyany», usti «bandagushanqi» sheshtadrumy darnum e chaphazanc vitcheli, ev «mtavor ankargapahutyun» -y hnchum e sparnaliqi pes, motavorapes ayspes: Varuzhan, mi sheghvir im sahmanagcac tchanaparhic, kam: inchpes es handgnum chentarkvel, Varuzhan…. Orinak vercru Vardanic kam Surikic, tesnum es, arajiny katarum e im bolor qmhatchuyqnery… erkrordy chi toghnum moranal: inch e qcnanqy…
Bayc: ancnenq araj:
Havelvac II
Gaghapharabanakan hermenevtikan ir verjnakan philisophayakan himnavorumy gtav: darnalov vogu gitutyan imacutyan tesutyun, qanzi verjinis mijocov usumnasirvum-ardzanagrvum en hogevor gorcuneutyuny, vogu ararkayakan, irakanoren goyutyun unecogh vitchaky, usti ymbrnel ayn: naxevaraj nshanakum e gtnel qez inch-or tiruytum: Hermenevtik verlucutyan arvesty gorcacvum er derevs antik dprocnerum: Homerosi anhaskanali kam dzhvar ynkalvogh teqsteri meknutyan hamar, vori ardyunqum Spinozan ir «Astvacabanakan-qaghaqakan traktat» -um (1670) xosum e Surb gri avandakan meknutyan veranayman anhrazheshtutyan masin: Hermenevtik metodi xndiry: inqd qez ev urishnerin haskanaln e, erb ayl zhamanakneri mardkanc u erevuytneri nerqin kapov gtnvum es idealakan miasnutyan ptuytum: veraprelov nranc phordzi hnaravorutyuny vorpes andznakan ev haytnaberum qo: derevs anhayt hnaravorutyunnery: Hermenevtikan henvum e mardu: bnutyany harabervelu ev ayd bnuyti: vorpes mshakutayin phasti, haytnaberman mijocov kyanqin harabervelun: Mardy chi karogh aprel mi ashxarhum, vortegh tegh chuni. qanzi kanhetana nra kerpary, miazhamanak ashxarh-patkeri nra ymbrnumy:
Anhati banakanutyuny, vorpes amboghjutyun, arandznakiacnum e verjinis «intersubyektivutyuny» (Shlayermaxer), bayc sa amenevin el chi nshanakum, vor cankacac teqst hamyndhanur e: Ays paragayum anhrazhesht en hamapatasxan mijin oghakneri phoxognutyunnery, voronc shnorhiv el hnaravor e anhatakanutyan haytnaberumy, qani vor zgacmunqneri artahaytutyuny derevs lezu che: Verstin dzevavorvoghy, sakayn, darnum e nor kerpar, vorin hamapatasxan steghcvum e ashxarhi ynkalman bolorovin nor patker:
Nerqin ays taracutyan mej el «hakadrvum en astvacakentronutyuny ev goyabanutyan himnakan dzevavorumy ev artacolvum e Astco: haraberakanoren ansahman goyutyuny: vorpes bacardzak amboghjutyun» (Kuzanaci): Mardu nerqin hnaravorutyunern ognum en nran anyndhat verakertvel, dzgtel azatutyan, usti motecumy aynpisi himnakan haskacutyunnerin, inchpisiq en philisophayutyuny ev grakanutyuny (neraryal antik aghbyurnery), hnaravor en dardznum irenc bazmakerputyan mej: ditarkel ashxarhamasery miavorogh erevuyty: grakanutyuny: Antik zhamanakneri ays xndiry, vorn aysor naev mer xndirn e u mezanic heto el klini, haytnagorcvum e groghi ymbrnumneri geghagitakan hamakargum, qani vor nranum amen inch bxum e anhatakan goyutyunic, nuynisk gitakcutyun-entagitakcutyun ancumy voch ayl inch e, ete voch liarzheq ancum ankrkneli Tiezerqi: Aystegh e aha, vor hamynkman skzbunqov hakadrutyan haskacutyuny hasnum e gorcarvogh ansahmanutyan, aydpisov motenalov avartunutyan, vorn ynkalum enq vorpes ancum goyutyan nor vitchaki kam ayl cnundi: phoxarkelov nranc eutyuny nuyn bnuyti ymbrnmamb u erevutacnelov sahmanavor abstrakcianer: irenc bazmativ atomneri azdecutyamb, voronq anverj phoqr en: Ays arumov, teqsti goyabanutyunn irakananum e arajin hertin sharzhman mijocov, tepet tvum e: teqsti irakanutyunn ansharzh e (tes V. Ayvazyan, «Gaghtni anuny»):
Heghinaky logosi nshanakutyuny ditarkum ev nra teghy voroshakiacnum e mtacoghutyan patmakan zargacman tiruytum, isk hangucayin verabermunqy hin, mijnadaryan ev nor ashxarhatesutyan arcarcman u erevutacman tiruytum e, logosn aystegh hamakargvum e arandznahatuk-oroshakiacvac imastov ev shrjanarvum vorpes naxasteghc miasnutyun, vory miavorum u shrjanarum e entagitakcutyan ev goyabanutyan haraberakcutyuny, qani vor ays erkusi yndhanrutyunn arden mitum e depi ayn druyty, vori mijocov Aristotely himnavorec ir metafizikayi tramabanutyuny («cogito sum»): Hetevabar datoghutyunn amenevin el miayn phoxshaghkapvac haskacutyunneri kam terminneri amboghjutyuny che, ayl anhati mtavor yntacqi hamakoghmani haraberutyuny ashxarhin: Metafizikakan eutyunneri sharzhumn inqnakaravarvogh e, ev «Gaghtni anun» -i hamakargy, vorqan el pndi akademikosy, ankanon kam anavart che:
«Gaghtni anuny» hanguyci meknutyan himqum petq er tesnel «linel» haskacutyuny, vorn avelin e, qan nshany, qani vor ayn bacahaytum e erevuyti euyty, vorin ays depqum hangecnum enq mer datoghutyunnery: Iroghutyunn ayspisov gorcarvum e anhati inqnutyan mijocov, u ete groghi mtacoghutyuny darnum e mer usumnasirutyan ararkan, uremn himnakan xndiry meknarkum e goyabanakan haraberutyuny, ayd isk pattcharov el Ayvazyani geghagitakan banadzeverum voch te anavartutyun ka, ayl aydpisin e mtahghacumy: ashxarhi ptuytin hamazor yntacq, ayd pattcharov el suyn druyty darnum e ayn, inch ka: yndgrkelov u artacolelov bolor erevuytneri linelutyan eutyuny: Ays arumov akademikosi motecumy fenomenologiakan e. irakanum ayn chi bacahaytum, chi artahaytum, cuyc chi talis, ayl hghum e lezvin, vorn el artadrum e ditarkvogh ararkan, qani vor «tesnel» ev «xosel» haskacutyunnery ays paragayum amboghjakan ev phoxkapakcvac chen: Havelem naev, vor Varuzhan Ayvazyani «Gaghtni anuny» essen tpagrvum e erkrord angam, arajiny: (Tes «Garun», 1997, tiv 5, mayis): Ayn zhamanak akademikosy artaroc vochinch chi nkatel nranum:
«Cankacac mtacoghutyun nerqin lezu e, ev ayd lezun el mijin e, qani vor nerqin xosqy dzgtum e artahaytutyan: Ayn ameny, inch dzgtum e hermenevtikayin, lezun e, qani vor ayn ameny, inch na voronum e, lezvi mej e» (Shlayermaxer): Ev ete anhrazhesht e hasnel mtqin, anhrazhesht e hasnel naev heghinaki lezvi akunqnerin, qani vor lezun amenic araj ashxarhic acancvogh phordzn e, ev mitqy: lezvi hnaravorutyunneri masin, aravel tesaneli e dardznum ashxarhy, ayn Urishy (metafizikakan avanduytov kam verjinis apakarucman), vori mijocov kareli e erkxosutyan mej mtnel u masamb hnaravor dardznel zhamanakakic verlucutyan nor skzbunqnern u metodnery:
Ayvazyani hamar aynpisi ymbrnumnery, inchpisiq en fenomenologiakan ego — n, noesis — y, noema — n (ego — cogito — cogitatum), kecutyuny, zhamanaky ev ayln, phoxakerpvum ev harabervum en lezvi ymbrnmany te teqsti nersum, ev te teqstic durs: Vorpes hishoghutyun: heghinaky nerkan ditum e ancyali permanent luysi nerqo («Patmutyun Mecn Kovkasi»), vorpeszi hasni kyanqi kayun, nerdashnak vitchakin ev karoghana ayn tesnel azat-handart yntacqi mej: iragorcelov ekzistencial goyabanutyan vogekochumy ev erki: ptuyti mijocov anyndhat krknvogh karuycy, vortegh barery sparum en irenc inqnuruyn nshanakutyuny, u cnvogh imasty phoxancvum e metafori tiruyt: Heghinaki tchakatagirn ays depqum teqst-entagitakcutyun hnaravorutyunn e: xosqi bacahaytman amboghjakanutyan sahmanneric durs, ur patkern ir sharunakakan yntacqov ynkalvum e vorpes fenomen, isk nra amenagravich arandznahatkutyuny naxadasutyan mej dzayni andradardzn e, vorn arnchvum e patker — kerpaphoxutyunnerin: miavorelov goyabanakan patkerasteghcman tarber astitchanakarger: Lezvi tiruytum goyavorvogh patkery, vorin hatuk en voroshaki miasnakanutyunn u avartunutyuny, steghcvum e yntacqi mijnordavorvac sharzhmamb ev heghinak — taracutyun kapi steghcmamb:
Gegharvestakan erki (aystegh: «Patmutyun mecn Kovkasi») konkret nyuti usumnasirutyan ev ayd arumov karciq haytnelu hamar akademikosy petq e kirarer hermenevtik metody, tekuz: miasnakanutyan yntacakargov: karucvacqayin — imastabanakan ev hamematakan — tipabanakan verlucutyamb, isk glxavor goyabanakan xndri arajadrman hamar anhrazhesht e arden fenomenologiakan motecum, vori mijocov voroshakioren kandradarnar teqstin u patkerin aynpes, inchpes nranq nerkayacvac en: irenc inqnabavutyan mej, ev ayn cher ynkalvi vorpes «bandagushanq», tepet, mtacum em, vor ays bary derevs Yuri Xachatryani «Akademikosi pertchanqn u tshvarutyuny» («Azg», 2006, 30 septemberi) qnnadatakan hodvacic mnacac nizaki ayn sur sayrn e, vor minch ors keghequm e akademikosin, ev na phordzum e sosk hogebanoren azatvel dranic: annpatak netelov Ayvazyani vepi hascein:
Havelvac III
Gaytakghutyuny, vor mardun arnchvogh artaqin ashxarhy nman e bnutyan ynkalman nyutakan vitchakin, vorn usumnasirum en fiziknery, artacolvum e entadrabar, usti kapvac nerqin u artaqin ashxarhi irakan u erevakayakan dixotomiayin: nor xndir e cnvum. ashxarhy, vortegh aprum enq, erkbever e. baci ayn, vor aprum enq artaqin ashxarhum, aprum enq naev mer nerqin ashxarhum, ev «ayd vayry nuynqan irakan e, vorqan mez shrjapatogh ashxarhy» (ays druyty haytnaberel en hogebannery XX daraskzbin), usti nergravvac linel voreve socialakan sharzhman mej: nshanakum e hstakecnel qo hetaqrqrutyunneri shrjanaky ev anvanel nranc, vovqer hakadrvum en ayd volortin:
«Ete phordzelu linenq, aynuamenayniv, ughghutyunner nshmarel ardi grakan hayacqnerum, apa kareli e arandznacnel Violet Grigoryani «Inqnutyuny» (ete vercanenq: kstacvi «Inqnagir», N.H.), Varuzhan Ayvazyani hermenevtikan («Gaghtni anuny») (orn ynkalelu ev apa usumnasirelu hamar petq e irapes canot linel Shlayermaxeri, Haydegeri, Diltayi, Gadameri, Deridayi, Lakani tesutyunnerin ev voch te miayn anunnery tal: N. H.), «Greterty», «Aktual arvesty»: Xosqy qnnadatakan hayacqi anhatakan hghumi masin che, ayl geghagitakan ughghutyan hayti, vor ughghordvum e grakan manifesti tesakan arajadrmamb», - grum e akademikosy («Eghici luys», 2011, tiv 2, ej 4), bayc moranum, vor «geghagitakan ughghutyan haytn» inqn iren chi cnvum ev artaqin ashxarhin arnchvogh tekuz erevakayakan arajyntacy bolorovin el anhetevanq iroghutyun che. artaqin ashxarhi het anhati haraberutyunnerum karogh en steghcvel voroshaki shrjadardzer, ev «geghagitakan nor ughghutyan hayty», vor «ughghordvum e grakan manifesti tesakan arajadrmamb», shat hangist karogh e dzevavorvel naev anhati «qnnadatakan hayacqi anhatakan hghumic» durs: (tiv 2, ej 4) nuyn anhati geghagitakan nor hayti himqin, qani vor nerqin hogebanakan irakanutyuny vstahutyunn e hogebanakan angitakic ayn ashxarhi handep, vory krum e mardn ir nerqin tiruytum, usti socialakan ashxarhy phophoxvogh irakanutyunn e ev bolorovin tarber hogebanutyamb mardkanc ashxarhy, voronc erevakayutyan shnorhiv el irakananum e ayn, tepet mijandznakan haraberutyunnerum goyutyun chuni kayun «irn inqnin» vitchaky, vorn anhrazhesht e bacahaytel: Ayd pattcharov el phak diskursn irakanum tesaneli e ayn zhamanak, erb haghtaharum e tvyal gettoyi hetaqrqrutyunneri shrjanaky ev sksum e taphancel social-qaghaqakan haghordakcutyan hamakargery:
Inch verabervum e «Greterti» ughghutyany: kapvac eritasard serndi phordzarutyany: «eritasard serndi phordzarutyan het kapvac ughghutyun» (S.S.), apa ayspisi ughghutyan masin arajin angam em lsum, erevi nor nvatchum e (N.H.): Ev ete suyn «andradardzy», inchpes nshum e akademikosy, petq e npasti hetagayum «nyuti grakanagitakan hamakargmany», apa inchu e «Norq» handesn yndhanrapes durs mnacel hodvacagri tesadashtic: Ayspisi baner…:
Havelvac IV
XX dari grakan sharzhumneri patkern aylazan e: rusakan filonovyan socialakan utopiayi iracumic minchev protosyurrealizm, nrbatchashak hedonizm kam grakan misticizm, voroncic yuraqanchyury mitum e depi «noruyty», bayc xorqayin che: Aydpes dzevavorvecin naev antifayi, bnapahpanakan sharzhman ev feministakan aktivizmi shrjanaknery Rusastanum:
Derevs 1970-akan tvakannerin dzevavorvec postmodernizmi artahaytutyan dzeveric arajiny: «soc-art» -y: aylyntrakan arvesti shrjanaknerum: Ayn hakadrvum er 70-akanneri xorhrdayin gaghapharaxosutyany, uner parodik bnuyt, miavorum er «socrealizm» ev «pop-art» haskacutyunnery, ev minch aysor sharunakum e ir artahaytutyuny gtnel aynpisi cucahandesnerum, inchpisiq en: «Zen d’ Art» -y, «Elles» -y, «Gender check» -y: Postmodernistakan koghmnoroshumy, vor mitum e depi social-qaghaqakan, kronakan, hogebanakan, mshakutabanakan meknutyan gaghtnagrvac nshanayin hamakargery, miazhamanak hrazharumn e patmutyan ughghagic motecumic u nra nerqin tiruytum haytnaberum e nor hatkanishner, inchpisiq en: «zhamanakakcutyuny vorpes phordzarkvogh patmutyun. (1980-1990-akan tvakanner)», «Herosakan postmodernizm (1980-akan tvakanner)», «Kompostmodernizm. nor mardabanutyun», «Hayreniq», «Ikonosfera» ev ayln: Irakanum ays bolor dzevavorvac u dzevavorvogh erevuytneri himqum social-hogebanakan xndirner en, voronq kazmavorvum en anhatakan hogebanutyan himqin:
Postmodernizmi darashrjany, vory phoxarinec modernizmin, kareli e dzevakerpel motavorapes ayspes: ancum nor goyakerpi, tepet hasarakutyan kolektiv angitakcutyan tiruytum eakanoren vochinch chi phoxvel, patmutyuny noric pttvum e nuyn ritmov, ev amenur tevacum e derevs xorhrdayin artadroghakan tarineri hasarakutyan nuyn urvakany: Ays yntacqum miayn hascrel en aravelapes zarganal erku zugaher lezuner: metahogebanakan, vorn arnchvum e phasterin, ev fenomenologiakan: imasti u erevakayutyan: Angitakic hogebanakan vitchaky hghum e iradrutyunneri obyektiv nkaragrman tiruyt, erb artaqin ashxarhi ynkalumy darnum e Egoyi mas, vorn el steghcumi gorcoghutyan mijocov anhati erevakayutyuny hascnum e ir unecaci (naev: nerdrumneri u spaseliqneri) gitakcmany: Ays aritov ushagrav e hetevyal mitqy: «Ayzhm hetaqrqir e ditel «Aktual arvesti» geghagitutyuny: himq yndunelov «I polit arti» verjin manifesty (3-rd hark)», - grum e akademikosy, um erevi tvacel e, te «sahun qaylerov annshmar, vorpes qnqush muti tev» (V. Teryan) kareli e ancnel handesi xoragri vrayov ev «3-rd harki manifestic» artagrel aktual arvesti «geghagitutyan» ev «anyndgrkeli sahmanneri» masin makdirnery, voronq Arman Grigoryani u ir ynkerneri koghmic grvel en 1987 tvakani hulisin Paniveyzhis qaghaqum ev handisavor erdumi het miasin tpagrvac en handesi 66-67-rd ejerum, u hashivnery hamarel phakvac, qanzi vov khandgni zhxtel: mec grakanagitutyuny aydpes e ararvum: Sakayn dranq verapatmelu kariqn amenevin chkar, qani vor «aktual arvesty» bnutagrelu nor phordz che: Ayd ameni phoxaren, qich gitak yntercoghin khetaqrqren hetevyal harceri patasxannery: «Inchu: «I polit art» », che vor erevuyty «polit art» anunn e krum, «inchu: «3-rd Harki arajin manifest» ev «inchu: 3-rd Harki verjin manifest» » ev vor Vardan Azatyani «Hishoghutyun ev kam: moracutyun» hodvacn ughghakioren arnchvum e ays xoragrerin ev ayln: Inchpes tesnum enq, trvac chen ayn harceri patasxannery, voronq eakanoren kkoghmnoroshein ev kbacahaytein voch miayn «aktual arvesti» geghagitutyuny, ayl gone nra vorosh hatkanishner: Akademikosi koghmic Arman Grigoryani erdman bnutagrumn aveli absurd e, qan veronshyal makdirneri artagrutyuny. «Sa Arman Grigoryani erdumn e, vor mi eakan chaphov artahaytum e aktual arvesti bnuytn u ughghutyuny»: Hetaqrqir e, ayd inchpes: «Sirel inqs indz, vorpeszi sirem urishnerin // Steghcagorcel miayn hiacmunqov // Chlinel havaknot// Ete chkatarem erdums, togh korchem naxkin Sovetakan Miutyan het miasin» (A. G.) togheric akademikosy haskacav «aktual arvesti» «bnuytn u ughghutyuny» (???):
Chem andradarnum naev akademikosi: tarber heghinakneri hodvacneri veraberyal xorhrdacutyunnerin, qani vor drancic ev voch meky subyektiv molorutyan sahmany chi hatel, ayn e: bolor erevuytnery hangecnel ynddimutyan gaghapharaxosutyany: moranalov, vor inqy nuynpes anmasn che nmanatip nerboghneric, vor zhamanakin nvirel e Levon Ter-Petrosyanin u heto, iren hatuk xohamtutyamb, xmbagrel sephakan kensagrutyunic (che vor ayzhm urish zhamanakner en):
Isk aha: «Handesi suyn hamari lusancqnerum haytnvum en Syuren Kirkegory, Umberto Ekon, Emil Sioran («Gogol»), Rudolf Kasnery, Karl Yaspersy, Xorxe Borxesy. Alber Kamyun ev urishner, voronc druytnern ozhandakum en handesi heghinaknerin: himnavorelu geghagitakan u patma-sociologiakan kategorianeri genetikan» (tiv 2, ej 5) mitqy chaphazanc vitcheli e, qani vor voch miayn suyn hamary: («Aktual arvest» 2008, tiv 6), aylev myus bolor hamarnern ughekcvum en lusancqnerum teghakayvac nyuterov, voronc mijocov himnavorvum e voch miayn «geghagitakan u patma-sociologiakan kategorianeri genetikan», aylev nerkayacvum en zugaher ayl irakanutyunner, voronq goyabanakan aravelaguyn hnaravorutyun en apahovum voch miayn heghinakneri, aylev yntercoghi hamar (orqan el vor polit-art-i hamar karevorvum e xosqi brutal (dazhan) vitchaki tuyltvutyuny. sahmanin mot, bayc: arvestov), isk lusancqnerum handesi goyabanutyunn u «genetikan» himnavorum en voch miayn otar, aylev hay heghinaknery: Isk aha Vardan Fereshetyani «Syoren Kirkegor kam antesaneli karnavaly» essen ev Syoren Kirkegoric «Dzhbaxtaguyny» nra targmanutyamb tegh en gtel handesi ejerum ev voch te lusancqnerum ev kariq unein lurj andradardzi: Handesi tarber hamarnerum, ayd tvum ev: 2008, tiv 6-um, tpagrvel en naev Levon Nersisyani dasaxosutyunnery, vor amenakarevor nyuteric en, bayc zarmanalin vorn e: voch mi xosq dranc masin:
«Gaghapharn inqn arden karogh e linel arvesti obyekt: Hayecakargayin arvesti glxavor npataky nergorcutyunn e anhati gitakcutyan vra ev voch te zgacmunqi kam tesoghutyan» (Sol Levit): «Aktual arvesty» dzevavorvel e germanakan «aktuelle kunst» -ic, vory entadrum e naev «ardiakan arvest» ymbrnumy: Ayn karogh e phoxarinel «avangard», «modernizm»: XX dari arajin ev «postmodernizm» haskacutyunnerin: erkrord kesi hamar: miazhamanak arnchvelov social-qnnadatakan volortin: dadaizm, syurrealizm kam: flyuksus: Aveli ush ir nerqin kerpaphoxumneri shnorhiv «aktual arvesty» (naev: grakanutyuny) nor gorcaruyt dzerq berec (yst akademikosi: «inch-inch ezrer» gtav) . ayn e: qaghaqakan: Bayc «qaghaqakanutyun» haskacutyuny aystegh payqari avandakan shrjanakic durs e, qani vor zhamanakakic arvesti (naev: grakanutyan) ays «tevn» ir qaghaqakanutyamb masnatum e taracutyuny ev himnavorelov: arandznacnum phordzy, miazhamanak irakanacnelov patkeri u marmni verabashxum, vorn el ynkalvum e vorpes qaghaqakanutyun:
Ete mi phoqr ayl kerp ditenq anverjutyuny, apa ayn kanvanenq aktual anverjutyun, tepet inch-or haverzhakan, anphophox erevuyt hnaravor e nuynpes darna aynpisin, vor ynkalvi nuyn kerp. ayd depqum ayn evs kdarna verjavor: Bolorovin verjers «polit — art — 2010, top — 3», «aktual arvesti» mi aydpisi artahaytutyunn er rusakan «Voyna» skandalayin art — xmbi heghinakayin cucadrutyuny: «Liteyniy x@y Voyni», Aleqsandr Plucer — Sarnoyi glxavorutyamb, vori sakral imastn irakanacrel ein «bacvogh kamrji» mi koghmum: hska fallosi tesqov: Zhamanakakic grakan aydpisi ateghcagorcutyuny entadrum e social-qaghaqakan mikrokosmos. vory gegharvestakan tesq stanalov: bnutagrum e anhatakan gitakcutyan apakarucumy, inchpes naev angitakic erevakayutyan ev pashtpanakan mijocneri gorcyntacnern aranc anhati hogebanutyan aghtchatman:
Froydi: aravel vagh shrjanum arajadrac hogebanakan modelnerum hasarakutyunn ynkalvum e vorpes anhatakanutyunneri miasnutyun, aveli tchisht, ger-anhatakanutyunneri miasnutyun, voronc miavorum e erevakayutyan tiruyti nuynakanutyuny: Aveli ush na nshum e naev aydpisi anhatakanutyunnery miavorogh kapery, voronc hogebanutyan mijocov steghcvum en socialakan fenomenner, usti vorqan el qaghaqakan hagust kri polit-art-y, mievnuyn e uni social-hogebanakan henq, qani vor «anhati institucional miutyunnery miavorogh tarreric ays mekn ynkalvum e vorpes pashtpanutyun hogebanakan koghmnaki anhangstutyunneric» (J. Elliott, «The social system as a defence against persecutory and depressive anxiety», in Klein, Heimann and Money-Kyrle, eds. New Directions in Psicho-Analysis. London: Tavistock, 1955, pp. 478-498) . Ays metodnery miazhamanak pashtpanutyan kolektiv dzever en, qani vor anhatnery liirav en: ogtagorcelu hasarakakan institutnery andznakan hogebanakan tiruyti hamar: Ays depqum hasarakakan institutnern el irenc nersum en dzevavorvum arandzin submshakuytner kam gettoner, voronq, tepet angitakic, sakayn gorcarvum en anhatneri koghmic:
Nihilizmi u ankeghcutyan hakadrumy verjin hashvov yntercoghin hascnum e ayn mtqin, vor ete arvestum (kam grakanutyan mej) nihilizmy mekn e: ymbostutyun hanun ymbostutyan, apa graqnnadatutyan mej hetevyaln e: andradardz hanun andradardzi: U ete arajin erevuyti mijocov antesanelioren anjatvum e cankacac gegharvestakan ughghutyan himqy, apa erkrordy mitum e sosk subyektiv shahaditakan nkrtumneri: Ayspisi «andradardznern» ayl kerp ches kochi, qan: bnazd socialakan u qaghaqakan irakanutyan handep, vori masin heghinaknery xosum en graqnnadatutyan lezvov: miavorelov iradardzutyunnery, taracutyuny ev zhamanaky aynpes, vor ayd ameny sksum e «andradardzi» tesq yndunel ev carayel voroshaki xmbavorumneri (klanneri): Social-qaghaqakan ayd bnazdy, vor phulayin bnuyt uni (tarin mek angam), hushum e hasarakutyan (ays depqum naev: qnnadati) voch shat heru xorhrdayin ancyaly, vorn ayzhm veraprukayin vitchakum e:
Havelvac V
Andradardzy Xoren Gasparyani «Hnaravor e linel hay mec banasteghc» («Hraparak», 2010, tiv 245, ej 5) hodvacin, bazum tvacyal patasxanneri het cnum e ev harcer, voronc patasxannery chen trvel, ev akademikosi ditarkumnery ays arumov teri en: Ushagrav e: «mec hay banasteghc, te hay mec banasteghc» harcadrumy, «errord ashxarhi» grakanutyun» ymbrnumy, ev apa: groghi mec kam hanrahayt linely: Xoselov «mec hay» ev «hay mec» banasteghc ymbrnman masin: akademikosy vkayakochum e Vilyam Saroyani grakan tchakatagirn u erevuyty: nshelov nran hatkapes lezvi yntrutyan tiruytum, miazhamanak moranalov, vor Vilyam Saroyany voch te banasteghc e, ayl: ardzakagir:
Vkayakochelov Sheqspiri hantchary: «orpes chaphanish lezvakan gorconi ev patmakan mec iradardzutyunneri kizaket (te kizaketum: N.H.) linelu paragaynutyamb», akademikosy nshum e, vor ays «erku gorconnern arka en naev mec azgeri ashxarhaqaghaqakan ardi hangamanqnerum» (???), moranalov evs erku: hogebanakan ev ashxarhayacqi anhrazhesht u voch pakas gorconnery, voroncic arajiny havasarakshrum e taghandi u steghcagorcakan procesum mtacoghutyan naxnakan patkeracumneri u nor hayacqneri steghcman mijev, erkrordy: socialakan zargacman shrjaphulum bnutagrum e groghi u hasarakutyan mtavor kensakerpi tesakanacvac dzevery (hayacqneri hamakargy ev mardu dery nranum), vortegh lucvum en naev imasti u arzheqi harcery ev irakananum e kyanqi gaghaphary:
Ays arumov groghi mtapatkerayin phophoxutyunnery: kapvac nuyn ashxarhaqaghaqakan u patmakan mec iradardzutyunneri kizaketum haytnvelun, yndhup minchev «irn inqnini» veradzevakerpumy, vory karevor e nra kazmaqandman (dissolva) tesankyunic, cnvum en hogebanakan averacutyan hatkanishov, bazhanvum maseri (PS) ev bnoroshvum vorpes veradardz gitakcutyan tiruyt, aysteghic el: «errord ashxarhi» groghi, nra grakanutyan, tekuz: ibrev «zoh» nerkayanalu axtanishy (hogebanakan gorcony), vori depqum groghy mshtakan tatanoghutyan: hasunacman kam fiksaciayi bevernerum e, vorn ir liarzheq artahaytutyunn e gtnum lezvi u ashxarhayacqi miasnakanutyan tiruytum:

Kecutyan philisophayutyuny zhxtvum e zhamanaki avandakan haskacutyamb, inchpes zhamanakayin chyndmijvogh keteri ankax hajordakanutyuny u darnum kecutyan yntacqic bxogh ankax goyutyan patmakanutyun, usti «ur en zhamanakakic sheqspirnery» harcadrumy darnum e voch aktual, qani vor zhamanaky darnum e nerqin, anhatakan ashxarhi ynkalman mas, vortegh nerqiny phoxnertaphancman drutyunn e (ancyali, nerkayi u apagayi) hishoghutyan, husheri, npatakaharmarutyan henqin:
Hajord ditarkumy: «Ev inchu amerikyan ispanalezu grakanutyunn arajadrum e hamashxarhayin tchanachman anunner, isk zhamanakakic Ispanian, aynuamenayniv, chuni ir Markesy, Borxesy, Kortasary, Koelyon: Der avelin, ispanaci grogh Xavier Moriasy gnahatvel e (um koghmic — N. H.) vorpes Markesi hetevord»:
Sksenq skzbic: Arajadrvogh latinaamerikyan heghinakneric Markesy kolumbaci ispanalezu heghinak e, Borxesn u Kortasary: argentinaciner en: Verjin erkusic arajiny: 1914-in, isk erkrordy: 1951-in hastatvel ein Evropayum: Chorrord heghinakin: Koelyoyin, terevs miayn haytniutyamb, vorn artasahmanum yndameny kanonavor grakan PR — i ardyunq e, kareli e dasel arajin ereqi koghqin (tepet: nuynisk dran hamadzayn chem, N.H.), isk geghagitakan-philisophayakan hghumnerov na bolorovin tarber e u vorpes grogh: tuyl, ev es voch mi paymanov nran chei nshi Markesi, Borxesi u Kortasari koghqin: Tpavorutyunn ayn e, te Koelyon nshvel e sosk ayn pattcharov, vor asvi, te zhamanakakicnerin el gitenq:
Inch verabervum e: Xavier Moriasin, apa nran Markesi hetevord kareli e hamarel terevs miayn veperi karucman: «anyndhat veradardzi» nicsheakan mexanizmi ogtagorcman arumov, vory mghvum e aravelapes lezvi tiruyt, ev xorhurd ktayi hargarzhan akademikosin grqeri shapiknerin kam titghosaterterin grvac trafaretayin canucumneric dzernpah mnal, qani vor Markesy «mogakan realizmi» himnadirn e («Haryur tarva menutyun», «Nahapeti ashuny»), vori hetevordnern en Borxesn u Kortasary, isk Xavier Moriasy hogebanakan trillerneri varpet e («Spitak sirt», «Maqarman zhamin vaghy hishir im masin» ev ayl gorcer):
Kanxatesel skzbunqoren ayl karucvacq apagayi grakanutyan (mshakuyti) hamar, qich e hnaravor, qani vor phordzy: nkaragrel postmodernistakan hogekerpy vorpes pttvogh sharzhich: miayn iren hatuk chaphagrumnerov irakanacvogh patmutyamb u vaxtchanaketin hasnogh nshannerov, hatuk e miayn postmodernistakan grakanutyany, usti «inchu zhamanakakic Ispanian chi arajadrum hamashxarhayin anunner» harcadrumy nuynpes darnum e voch aktual, qani vor postmodernistakan nuyn hogekerpy: vorpes pttvogh sharzhich, sharunakum e derevs zarganal: Ays grakanutyan karevor hatkanishneric meky Vogu cragri (gaghaphari) apakarucumn e, vory miazhamanak nerarum e naev qristoneakan metapatmakanutyuny, u handipum avandakan-kronakan ughghvacutyun unecogh grakanutyan ashxarhynkalman koghmic merzhmany: Ays arumov petq e hashvi arnel vagh kronakan zhamanakashrjani mshakuyti u patmutyan phoxharaberutyunnery, socialakan u gaghapharabanakan gorcyntacnery, ev haziv te nkatvi ayd havasarakshrutyan xstiv tatanum depi kronakan grakanutyuny: Ughghaki kdzevavorvi nor verabermunq aydpisi grakanutyan nkatmamb, vory karajadri nor kosmo-hamakarg ev bolorovin ayl goyabanutyun: «Armatakan ancumy verjic skzbi: mitum e mtacoghutyan modusi», - grum e Epshteyny, ev arajarkum «proto» naxdiry, vory kphoxarini «post» -in, nshelov erevuyti fenomenalutyuny (Mixail Epshteyn, De’but de siesle, ili Ot post- k proto-. Manifest novogo veka, Znamya, 2001, N5), vori tchakatagirn apagayinn e, aveli tchisht ayn apagayum hnaravor erevuytneric mekn e, inchpes Liotari arajadrac paradoqsy: «apagan ancyalum»: Iharke, nor steghcvogh grakanutyan kazmuyty karogh e yndgrkel naev ancyali grakanutyan tarrery, sakayn ktarberakven dranq, te voch, dzhvar e asel, usti ancyal-apaga ays ancumy, vor sksel e avangardizmy u sharunakum e postmodernizmy, ayzhm kariq uni nor verahaytnagorcumneri:
Haykakan postmodernizmy inqnatip — inqnakaravarvogh bnazdner uni, ev aydpisi mtacoghutyan gcern u goyakerpy mshakuyti tiruytum, steghcum en vaxtchani kam grakanutyan tchgnazhami tpavorutyun ayn depqum, erb hnaravor che haytnaberel ayd «nor» erevuyti (aystegh: grakanutyan) tesaneli u haghtaharvogh hatkanishnery: Yuri Lotmani mi ditarkumy, te paytyunov irakanacogh ev sharunakakan gorcyntacnery mshakuytum ughekcvum en sharzhman erku tiperov: «sharunakakan», vory kanxateseli e ev iragorcvum e avanduyti sahmannerum, ev «hatuytavor»: ankanxateseli kam dzhvar kanxateseli, vorn ughekcvum e paytyunov ev, anjatvelov avanduytic, steghcum e ir skzbunqnern unecogh geghagitakan nor fenomen, hangecnum e ayd gaghapharin («Mshakuyt ev paytyun», 1992):
«Hetkarucvacqabanutyun», «apakarucum», «postmodernizm» haskacutyunnery hay grakanutyan mej nor volort steghcecin, miazhamanak grogh hasarakutyany mghelov tarabever, voch miagic kam ughghagic gegharvestakan mtacoghutyan tiruyt: nerarelov mshakutapatmakan darashrjanneri amboghjakanutyuny u mghelov gri bolor tesakneri u tiperi tirapetman: nuyn heghinaki mej bacahaytelov arvestagetin, philisophayin, hogebanin, patmabanin, grakanagetin, mshakutabanin, inchpes Varuzhan Ayvazyani paragayum e:
Hnaravor e, sranq, iroq, lurj xndirner en mshakutayin mi voghj darashrjani, ayd tvum ev hay grakan irakanutyan hamar, vortegh iragorcvum e postmodernistakan «goyutyan payqari» arajin phuly, u dzevavorvum mshakutabanakan-grakan nor hasarakutyun, usti Dostoevsku «kaciny» anverj ptuytneri ays shrjaptuytum mievnuyn e amen angam hangelu e nuyn ketin, u gushak-qnnadatnery grancelu en miayn nra «elqern u mutqery»:
H.G.
Petq e xostovanel, vor npataks hargarzhan akademikosi «Andradardzy» qnnadately kam nranum inch-inch bactoghumner gtnely che (Astvac mi arasce), ayl, inchpes akademikosn e nshum: «mer hishoghutyunic grete otarvac mtavor kargapahutyun» ev «hamyndhanur gorshutyun» EREVUYTNERI armatnery tesaneli dardznely, te vorteghic karogh ein i hayt gal, vortegh enq korcrel «grakan-hasarakakan mtqi kargn u kargapahutyuny», ev kam vortegh e taqnvac ayd nexac armtiqov u tchentcherahotov li zambyughy: Te che stacvum e: grakanagitutyan mej el enq aysorva bzhshkutyan nman axtoroshum. tesnum ev buzhum enq miayn hetevanqy: aranc qnnabanelu klinikakan cagumnabanutyuny: