AZh naxkin phoxnaxagah Arphine Hovhannisyany feysbuqyan ir ejum grel e. «Bac namak Nikol Phashinyanin. «Konsensus minus intelekti masin».

Hargeli paron Phashinyan, Hargeli Nikol, erkar ei mtacum: andradarnam, ardyoq, Dzer ayn artahaytutyany, te «Hayastany dzaxoghvac petutyun» e, te, aynuhanderdz, toghnem, vor patmutyan grkum mna hertakan anhajogh dzevakerpumy։ Bayc, i verjo, vorosheci mi ogtakar carayutyun matucel։ Ev ayspes, 2005-ic sksac: Xaghaghutyan himnadramy ev «Foreign Policy» amsagiry hraparakum en dzaxoghvac petutyunneri (failed state) indeqsy։ Hatkanshakan e, vor voroshaki pahic sksac: indeqsy veranvanvec xoceliutyan indeqsi (fragile state), qani vor petutyunnery, ayspes asac, inqnasirutyun en drsevorel u payqarel, vor irenq chanvanven dzaxoghvac։ Naxyntrel en xoceli bary, qanzi ays kam ayn tiruytum kam bolorum miasin karogh en linel aydpisin: ays kam ayn chaphov: Ays indeqsy heghinakavor e ev shat e mejbervum hatkapes gitakan shrjanaknerum, qani vor hamaparphak e: nerarelov 12 chaphanishner: petutyan anvtangutyunic minchev qaghaqakan, social-tntesakan gorconnery։ Yuraqanchyur tari indeqsy kazmelu hamar usumnasirvum e mot tasy hazar aghbyur, mshakvum e 40-45 milion hodvac ev zekuyc։ 2019-in amenaxoceli erkiry, aysinqn: varchapeti sirac ezrutabanutyamb: «dzaxoghvacy», hamarvum e Emeny: zbaghecnelov arajin teghy, isk amenakayuny Finlandian e ir 178-rd teghov։ Hayastany (105) ays zekuycum erbeve, krknum em: erbeve chi ditarkvel vorpes dzaxoghvac։ Avelin: verjin tasy tarineri yntacqum, aysinqn: yst Dzez «dzaxoghvac» karavarman zhamanakashrjanum barelavel e ir dirqery: tasy tarva yntacqum grancelov 7.6 ketov arajyntac։ Ays tari evs Hayastany (te kuzeq: dzer Nor Hayastany) barelavel e dirqery, sakayn kan cucanishner, voronq ankum en aprel, u dranq mtacogh mardu hamar shat mtahogich en։ 2019-i indeqsov, aysinqn: Dzer «mardakentron» karavarutyan ishxanutyan oroq, Hayastanic ugheghneri artahosqy hasel e 7 tarva maqsimumin։ Mek ayl tiv: gorcogh qaghaqakan uzhin trvogh indeqsy, (gitakanoren: elitaneri nkatmamb verabermunqy) mnacel e nuyny։ Phastoren, i hetchuks bolor pndumneri, ishxanaphoxutyan gorcony, karces te, mec azdecutyun chi unecel։ Hamozvac em: hajord tari, yst arzhanvuyn, kgnahatven datakan ishxanutyan nkatmamb tchnshumnery, qaghaqakan hetapndumnery , annkat chi mna dataranneri shrjaphakman «pharahegh» akcian ev menq, iharke, ays arumov kunenanq «arajyntac»։

Hargeli paron varchapet, xndrum em, ete aysuhet evs andimadreli e Dzer cankutyuny Hayastany anvanel «dzaxoghvac» petutyun, apa gone kirareq hamashxarhayin ezrutabanutyamb xoceli bary։ U ete irakanum goyutyun uni nman phastatught, ayn tvoghnerin el hordoreq yntercel mijazgayin phastatghter, avelin: ynterceluc heto dranq matucel tchshgrtutyamb։ Dzer eluytum krkin kang araq Dzer koghmic aynqan sirvac, aynqan ognogh, aynqan anhrazhesht bari: «naxkin» bari vra: Erku ditarkum unem ayd arnchutyamb։ Nax Duq anyndhat, arit-anarit varkabekum eq bolor naxkinnerin: tarberutyun chdnelov mijocneri mijev u havasarecnelov bolorin u amen inch: Baci ayd, Dzer shurteric chi hnchel voreve bar ayn masin, vor naxkinnery inch-or mi banum, tekuzev annshan hajoghutyun en grancel u tchisht en eghel: Chxorsheciq angam anvanel naxkin bolor pashtonyanerin bri u tget: moranalov hpancik hayacq netel dzer karavarutyan mi sharq andamneri kam dzer merdzavoraguyn shrjapatum gtnvogh gorcararneri vra, voronc mej shatery NAXKIN en:
I dep, inchu ayd hayacqy chgceciq nerkaneri vra, vortegh achq e cakum dilentantizmi u kayun inqnasiraharvacutyan gerdozavorumy։ Miayn chaseq vochinch ksovoren, angam varsahardary nax: sovorel e hardarel, heto miayn spasarkel։

inchpes patahec, vor phoxanak karavarman 1.5 tarva yntacqum Duq inqnerd hangeq ezrakacutyan petutyan inchpisin linelu veraberyal, dra masin ezrakacnum eq ayd «bri u tget» naxkinneri kazmac phastatghti himan vra: Baci ayd, inchu eq sxal hamarum ayn amenn, inch eghel e naxkinum, u mi hrashqi uzhov hamarum, vor henc ays phastatughtn e tchisht: Guce ayd naxkinnery, inchpes amen ban en «dzaxoghel», naev aystegh en sxal arel:
I dep, ete ayd phastatughty goyutyun uni, apa asem, vor dra heghinaknery iroq himarutyan master klas en cuyc tvel, ev, inchpes mijazgayin phastatghtern en vkayum, dzez ughghaki xabel en։ Usti dran havataly voch ayl inch e qan «konsensus minus intelekt»։

Erkrord, yndameny shabatner araj amboghj ishxanakan qarozchameqenayov hraparakum eiq 2019-i arajin eramsyaki tntesakan atchi 7.2 tokos cucanishy u «hngamyaky: mek tarum» votchi hraparakumner anum: phoxakerpelov «eramsyaky: yot tarum» kargaxosi: Hima da hajoghutyun er, te dzaxoghum: Isk naxord karavarutyan ancyal tarva nuyn zhamanakahatvaci 10.6 tokosy megadzaxoghum er, te megahajoghutyun:

Aysqanic heto: xndranq u hordor Dzez․
• AAC Erevani qaghaqayin varchutyan peti naxkin teghakal u ayzhm AAC tnoren Artur Vanecyanin hordoreq, vor Dzez bacatri, vor petakan ev carayoghakan gaghtniq hraparakely hancagorcutyun e, i dep u cavoq: hertakany Dzer mec sharqi mej։
• Sahmanadrakan datarani Dzer sireli («Dzer srti naxagah») «naxagah» Vahe Grigoryanin hordoreq, vor Dzez bacatri, vor derevs 2010-inic ka SD voroshum, vori hamadzayn: phastatghti anvanumy chpetq e lini gaghtniq։
• HH Pashtpanutyan naxarari naxkin teghakal ev ayzhmyan pashtpanutyan naxarar Davit Tonoyanin hordoreq, vor Dzez bacatri: Anvtangutyan karevorutyan masin erbeq chi kareli moranal: U vor henc da e himnakan pattchary, vor menq indeqsum ERBEQ chenq hamarvel dzaxoghvac petutyun։ Dzer asac «dzaxoghvac» petutyuny aysqan tari BVoLVoR ishxanutyunneri ( 1-in, 2-rd ev 3 rd naxagahner) zhamanak HAJVoGhUTYAMB apahovel e Hayastani u Arcaxi anvtangutyuny:

Henc ayd anvtangutyan apahovumn e: zhoghovrdavarutyan u mnacaci hamadrmamb, vor mez tuyl e tvel mot ereq tasnyak ketov aveli bardzr dirq zbaghecnel, qan orinak dzer aynqan sirvac Vrastany, aynqan «kirt» Adrbejany ev aynqaaan heghaphoxakan Ukrainan։ Patkeracnum eq, ayd petutyunnery yst ayd indeqsi meznic aveli «dzaxoghvac» en, bayc erbeq nrancic ev voreve meki ghekavary: heghaphoxakan, te voch aynqan, iren tuyl chi tvel bardzradzaynel, vor irenq dzaxoghvac en, xoceli: miguce, bayc voch: dzaxoghvac։

• HH Azgayin zhoghovi naxkin patgamavor ev ayzhmyan varchapet Nikol Phashinyanin hordoreq, vor nerkayis varchapet Phashinyanin hordori: erbemn, miayn erbemn lsel ir naxkin eluytnern u mtqery։ Guce ayd zhamanak varchapety sksi ashxatel ev dzaxoghman meghavorner chphntrel: Patgamavor Nikoly varchapet Phashinyanin togh asi, vor menq: vorpes zhoghovurd, hajoghvac enq, petutyuny: nuynpes, isk te «dzaxoghvac» e harkavor gtnel, apa aydpisin arajin hertin togh hamari iren u ir timin:

I verjo, paron varchapet, patetik eluytneri phoxaren gone mtqum get mek angam standzneq patasxanatvutyun Hayastani u Arcaxi anvtangutyan ev barekecutyan hamar u gnaceq araj։ Hisheq: sharzhumy ynddem Serzhi er, ev voch hanun Nikoli: Hpart qaghaqacinery Nikolin varchapet en dardzrel voch te ory mi legend hyuselu, ayl gorcelu ev mardkanc kyanqy lavacnelu hamar, inchum ev es hajoghutyun em maghtum։
H.G. I dep, Mi havataceq nranc, vovqer qaghaqakan kuyr en anvanum Dzer bolor hajoghutyunnery chtesnoghnerin: Vstah mi egheq, vor nranq naxord varchapeterin nuyn banery chen asel, ev da nranc koghmic yndameny parzunak qaghaqakan hnarq che: sephakan qaghaqakan ambicianery bavararelu hamar։ Nman mardkanc masin inchpes asum en: kam lavy kam vochinch»։